The following table provides a summary of the complete record of each New Zealand manager including their progress in both the World Cup, Confederations Cup and the Nations Cup.
| Manager | New Zealand career | P | W | D | L | F | A | GD | Win % | Competitions |
|---|
| {{flagicon|New Zealand}} Selection Committee | 1922–1957{{WDL|decimals=1|38|14|3|21|for=91|against=129|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|England}} Ken Armstrong[1] | 1957–1964{{WDL|decimals=1|9|7|1|1|for=28|against=13|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|SFR Yugoslavia}} Ljubiša Broćić 1st Spell[1] | 1965–1966{{WDL|decimals=1|0|0|0|0|for=0|against=0|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|Hungary}} {{flagicon|Chile}} Juan Schwanner[1] | 1967–1968{{WDL|decimals=1|7|3|0|4|for=21|against=20|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|SFR Yugoslavia}} Ljubiša Broćić 2nd Spell[1] | 1969{{WDL|decimals=1|6|1|1|4|for=4|against=11|diff=yes}} | 1970 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|New Zealand}} Barrie Truman[1] | 1970–1976{{WDL|decimals=1|31|10|9|12|for=47|against=48|diff=yes}} | 1973 OFC Cup – winners
1974 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|England}} Wally Hughes[1] | 1977–1978{{WDL|decimals=1|7|5|1|1|for=23|against=4|diff=yes}} | 1978 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|England}} John Adshead 1st Spell[1] | 1979–1982{{WDL|decimals=1|46|22|11|13|for=89|against=53|diff=yes}} | 1980 Nations Cup – Group stage
1982 World Cup – Group stage |
| {{flagicon|England}} Allan Jones[1] | 1983–1984{{WDL|decimals=1|19|10|4|5|for=27|against=17|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|England}} Kevin Fallon[1] | 1985–1988{{WDL|decimals=1|32|17|5|10|for=72|against=32|diff=yes}} | 1986 World Cup – failed to qualify
1990 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|England}} John Adshead 2nd Spell[1] | 1989{{WDL|decimals=1|4|1|1|2|for=5|against=7|diff=yes}} | 1990 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|Scotland}} Ian Marshall[1] | 1990–1993{{WDL|decimals=1|16|7|1|8|for=27|against=16|diff=yes}} | 1994 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|Scotland}} Bobby Clark[1] | 1994–1995{{WDL|decimals=1|9|1|2|6|for=10|against=22|diff=yes}} | 1996 Nations Cup – semi-finals
1997 Confederations Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|Scotland}} Keith Pritchett[1] | 1996–1997{{WDL|decimals=1|9|2|1|6|for=7|against=17|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|Republic of Ireland}} Joe McGrath[1] | 1997–1998{{WDL|decimals=1|9|3|1|5|for=13|against=12|diff=yes}} | 1998 World Cup – failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|England}} Ken Dugdale[1] | 1998–2002{{WDL|decimals=1|34|15|6|13|for=55|against=34|diff=yes}} | 1998 Nations Cup – winners
1999 Confederations Cup – Group stage
2000 Nations Cup – Runners-up
2001 Confederations Cup – Failed to qualify
2002 World Cup – Failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|England}} Mick Waitt[1] | 2002–2004{{WDL|decimals=1|18|8|1|9|for=45|against=29|diff=yes}} | 2002 Nations Cup – Winners
2003 Confederations Cup – Group Stage
2004 Nations Cup – Third Place
2005 Confederations Cup – Failed to qualify
2006 World Cup – Failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|New Zealand}} Ricki Herbert[2][3] | 2005–2013{{WDL|decimals=1|60|22|14|24|for=75|against=93|diff=yes}} | 2008 OFC Nations Cup – Winners
2009 FIFA Confederations Cup – Group stage
2010 World Cup – Group stage
2012 Nations Cup – Third Place
2013 Confederations Cup – Failed to qualify
2014 World Cup – Failed to qualify |
| {{flagicon|England}} Neil Emblen[19] | 2014{{WDL|decimals=1|2|0|1|1|for=2|against=4|diff=yes}} |
| {{flagicon|England}} Anthony Hudson[4] | 2014–2017{{WDL|decimals=1|27|9|7|11|for=32|against=29|diff=yes}} | 2016 OFC Nations Cup - Winners
2017 Confederations Cup – Group stage
2018 World Cup – Failed to qualify |
|
1. ^1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 {{cite web|url=http://www.ultimatenzsoccer.com/NZRepSoccer/id162.htm|title=Coaching Records|author=|publisher=Ultimate New Zealand Soccer Website|date=|accessdate=31 July 2009}}
2. ^{{cite news|title=Soccer: Herbert named All Whites coach|url=http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=10112634|accessdate=13 June 2017|publisher=New Zealand Herald|date=25 February 2005}}
3. ^Herbert to step down after campaign. NZ Football. 20 November 2013.
4. ^1 {{cite web|url=https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/football/nz-teams/99123448/how-anthony-hudsons-all-whites-record-compares-with-ricki-herberts|title=How Anthony Hudson's All Whites record compares with Ricki Herbert's|author= Andrew Voerman|date=23 November 2017|newspaper=Stuff.co.nz}}