| Year | Winner | Other Nominees |
|---|
2010-2011
(27th) | The Amazing Race (CBS)- No Reservations (Travel Channel)
- Survivor (CBS)
- All-Stars (Bravo)
- The Voice (NBC)
|
2011-2012
(28th) | So You Think You Can Dance (Fox)- The Amazing Race (CBS)
- Dancing with the Stars (ABC)
- The Glee Project (Oxygen)
- The Voice (NBC)
|
2012-2013
(29th) | Shark Tank (ABC)- The Amazing Race (CBS)
- The Glee Project (Oxygen)
- Survivor (CBS)
- The Voice (NBC)
|
2013-2014
(30th) | RuPaul's Drag Race (Logo TV)- The Amazing Race (CBS)
- Shark Tank (ABC)
- Survivor (CBS)
- The Voice (NBC)
|
2014-2015
(31st) | The Chair (Starz)- The Amazing Race (CBS)
- Dancing with the Stars (ABC)
- RuPaul's Drag Race (Logo TV)
- Shark Tank (ABC)
|
2015-2016
(32nd) | Making a Murderer (Netflix)- Inside the Greatest Political Show on Earth (Showtime)
- The Great British Baking Show (PBS)
- I Am Cait (E!)
- MasterChef Junior (Fox)
- Survivor: Cambodia — Second Chance (CBS)
|
2016-2017
(33rd) | Scientology and the Aftermath (A&E)- Inside the Greatest Political Show on Earth (Showtime)
- The Great British Baking Show (PBS)
- The Keepers (Netflix)
- Shark Tank (ABC)
- Game Changers (CBS)
|
2017-2018
(34th) | Queer Eye (Netflix)- The Great British Baking Show (PBS)
- Nailed It! (Netflix)
- Project Runway (Lifetime)
- RuPaul's Drag Race (VH1)
|
1. ^{{cite web|url=http://tvcritics.org/tca-awards/|title=Past winners of the TCA Awards|publisher=Television Critics Association}}