There are over forty 19th-century buildings at Black Creek Pioneer Village, all of which are decorated and furnished according to the styles of the 1860s, some with the building's original furnishings.
Several of the buildings were originally constructed at their current location. The others were relocated from other communities in Ontario.
| Building | Photo | Year of construction | Original location | Architectural style | Relocated | Opened | Notes |
|---|
| Apple storage cellar | c. 1850 | Edgeley | Field stone and brick | 1976 | 1976 | The building was dismantled at its original site and reconstructed at Black Creek Pioneer Village. |
| Bolton Shop | 1865 | Bolton | 1968}} | 1973}} | Originally used by a merchant tailor. Houses a 19th-century photography studio. |
| Broom Maker's Shop | Sherwood | Square log | 1963}} | 1973}} | May have been first school in Maple. |
| Burwick House | 1844 | Woodbridge | Rural Georgian | 1958-08-13|dmy}} | Mika|Mika|Thompson|2000|p=39—40}} |
| Cemetery | 1845 | Current site | N/A | N/A | N/A | Last interment was in 1927. |
| Charles Irvine's Weaver's Shop; Printing Office | 1850 | Kettleby | Timber frame | 1968}} | 1971}} | Constructed as a temperance hall by the Sons of Temperance. Moved intact in 1968. Contains a functional Washington flat bed press, a Gordon press, and a flying shuttle loom. |
| Chicken House | c. 1860 | Kettleby | Round log | 1972}} | 1973}} |
| Church Drive Shed | 1860 | Vaughan | 1982}} | Used to provide covered parking for parishioner horses and buggies. Dismantled in the 1970s by the Credit Valley Conservation Authority. |
| Daniel Flynn House | 1858 | Newtonbrook | Ontario classic style | 1959}} | 1960}} |
| Daniel Flynn Boot and Shoe Shop | 1858 | Newtonbrook | 1963}} |
| Daniel Stong’s First House | 1816 | Current site | Squared log | N/A | 1958}} | Was used as Stong residence until 1832, then repurposed as an outbuilding. |
| Daniel Stong's Second House | c. 1832 | Current site | Squared log on fieldstone foundation | N/A | 1960}} |
| Daniel Stong Smokehouse | c. 1820 | Current site | Squared log | N/A | 1960}} | Rebuilt in 1965 because of fire. |
| Daniel Stong Grain Barn | 1825 | Current site | N/A | 1960}} | One of the buildings original to the site. |
| Dickson Hill School | 1861 | Dickson Hill | 1960}} | Typical of the area's one-room schoolhouses of the period. The building was dismantled, moved to its current site, and rebuilt. |
| Doctor's House | c. 1830 | Chinquacousy | Timber frame with wood sheathing, stucco finish | 1973}} | 1978}} | Connor|Connor|1991|p=104}} |
| Dominion Carriage Works | 1860 | Sebringville | 1973}} | 1976}} | Includes original tools and patterns. |
| Edgeley Rabbit Hutch | c. 1860 | Edgeley | Timber frame | 1970}} | 1971}} | Used by local farmer's to butcher animals. |
| Fisherville Church | 1856 | Fisherville | Greek Revival | 1960}} | 1962}} |
| Half Way House Inn | 1849 | Scarborough | Georgian | 1966}} | Mika|Mika|Thompson|p=48}} |
| Henry Snider's Cider Mill | c. 1940 | Elia | 1959}} | 1961}} | Mika|Mika|Thompson|2000|p=38}} |
| Laskay Emporium | 1845 | Laskay | Frame with false front | 1960-02-19|dmy}} | Reconstructed based on historical documents and photographs from 1911. |
| Limehouse Outhouse | c. 1840 | Limehouse | Neoclassical/Georgian | 1971}} | 1972}} |
| Mackenzie Barn | c. 1850 | Woodbridge | Timber frame on stone foundation |
| Mackenzie House | c. 1830 | Woodbridge | Log cabin |
| The Manse | 1835 | Richmond Hill | Neoclassical | 1978-10-07}} | Used as manse by reverend of the Richmond Hill Presbyterian Church. Moved to Black Creek Pioneer Village in two pieces. |
| Mennonite Meeting House | 1824 | Edgeley | Log building | 1976-10-15|dmy}} | Contains original furnishings. |
| Roblin's Mill | 1842 | Ameliasburg | 1964}} | Consists of original timbers, flooring, and machinery, except for the 1848 wheel, which was replaced with a smaller version. The building was scheduled for demolition before its acquisition. |
| Rose Blacksmith Shop | c. 1855 | Nobleton | Timber frame, board and batten | 1958}} | 1960}} |
| Samuel Stong House | c. 1855 | Vaughan | Log house |
| Snider Workshop | c. 1840 | Concord | 1967}} | Originally a second house for the Snider family, later used as a farm workshop. Moved to Black Creek Pioneer Village as a Canadian Centennial project by the Snider family. |
| Taylor Cooperage | c. 1850 | Paris | Timber frame with board and batten | 1976}} | 1988}} |
| Tinsmith Shop and Masonic Lodge | c. 1850 | Woodbridge | 1983}} | 1984}} | Mika|Mika|Thompson|2000|p=35}} Dismantled, moved, and reconstructed at current site. |
| Wilmot Township Hall | 1858 | Baden | Timber frame with clapboard siding | 1967}} | Housed the Fifth Division Court of the County of Waterloo. |