“The Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu”的意思、由来-开放百科全书

(in the original French Dialogue aux enfers entre Machiavel et Montesquieu ou la politique de Machiavel au XIXe siècle) is a political satire written by French attorney Maurice Joly in protest against the regime of Napoleon III, a.k.a. Louis-Napoléon Bonaparte who ruled France from 1848-1870. It was translated into English in 2002. Small portions were translated in 1967 as an appendix to Norman Cohn's Warrant for Genocide, which identifies it as the main source of the later Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

The piece uses the literary device of a dialogue of the dead, invented by ancient Roman writer Lucian and introduced into the French belles-lettres by Bernard de Fontenelle in the 18th century. Shadows of the historical characters of Niccolo Machiavelli and Charles Montesquieu meet in Hell in the year 1864 and dispute on politics. In this way Joly tried to cover up a direct, and then illegal, criticism of Louis-Napoleon's rule.

Summary

that one evening thinking of economist Abbé Galiani's treatise Dialogues sur le commerce des bleds ("Dialogues on the commerce in wheat")^[3]

and walking by Pont Royal, he was inspired to write a dialogue between Montesquieu and Machiavelli. The noble baron Montesquieu would make the case for liberalism; the Florentine politician Machiavelli would present the case for despotism.

Machiavelli claims that he "... wouldn't even need twenty years to transform utterly the most indomitable European character and render it as a docile under tyranny as the debased people of Asia". Montesquieu insists that the liberal spirit of the peoples is invincible. In 25 dialogues, step by step, Machiavelli, who by Joly's plot covertly represents Napoleon III, explains how he would replace freedom with despotism in any given European country: "... Absolute power will no longer be an accident of fortune but will become a need" of the modern society. At the end, Machiavelli prevails. In the curtain-line Montesquieu exclaims "Eternal God, what have you permitted!...".

The book was published anonymously (par un contemporain, by a contemporary) in Brussels in 1864

^[4] and smuggled into France for distribution, but the print run was seized by the police immediately upon crossing the border. The police swiftly tracked down its author, and Joly was arrested. The book was banned. On 25 April 1865, he was sentenced to 18 months at the Sainte-Pélagie Prison in Paris. The second edition of "Dialogues" was issued in 1868 under Joly's name

Campaigning against Napoleon III at the French constitutional referendum, 1870, Joly wrote an epilogue to his "Dialogue". It was published at Le Gaulois

Legacy

In the beginning of 20th century Joly's book was used as a basis for The Protocols of the Elders of Zion,^[9]

an infamous Russian-made antisemitic literary forgery. There is an abundance of evidence that The Protocols were lavishly plagiarized from Joly's book.^[10]^[11]

that in the Dialogue Joly plagiarized seven pages or more from a popular novel Les Mystères du peuple by Eugene Sue.^[17]

References

1. ^¹{{cite book | title = The Dialogue in Hell between Machiavelli and Montesquieu | author1 = Maurice Joly (author)| author2 = John S. Waggoner (translator) | publisher = Lexington Books | year = 2002 | isbn=0-7391-0337-7}}
2. ^{{cite book | author = Maurice Joly| title = Maurice Joly, son passé, son programme, par lui-même| publisher = Lacroix, Verbɶckhoven et Co.| location = Paris| year = 1870| url = http://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k113966c}}
3. ^{{cite book | author = Ferdinando Galiani| author-link = Ferdinando Galiani| title = Dialogues sur le commerce des bleds| location = London| year = 1770| url = http://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b8626898f}}
4. ^{{cite book | author = Maurice Joly | title = Dialogue aux enfers entre Machiavel et Montesquieu ou la politique de Machiavel au XIX^e siècle| publisher=A. Mertens et fils| location = Bruxelles | year = 1864| url = https://fr.wikisource.org/wiki/Dialogue_aux_enfers_entre_Machiavel_et_Montesquieu}}
5. ^{{cite book | title = Dialogue aux Enfers entre Machiavel et Montesquieu, ou la Politique au XIXe siècle, par un contemporain [Maurice Joly] | author = Maurice Joly| publisher = Tous les libraires| location = Bruxelles | year = 1868| url = http://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k5427027b}}
6. ^{{cite journal| author = Maurice Joly| date = 30 April 1870| issue = 664| pages = 2–3| title = Dialogue aux Enfers entre Machiavel et Montesquieu. Épilogue.| url = http://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k519820w| language = French| journal = Le Gaulois : littéraire et politique | location = Paris}}
7. ^{{cite journal| author = Maurice Joly| title = Dialogue aux Enfers entre Machiavel et Montesquieu. Epilogue.| language = French| journal = La Cloche 2 May 1870 - 10 May 1870}}
8. ^{{cite book | author = F. Leclercq| title = Le Plébiscite, épilogue du dialogue aux enfers entre Machiavel et Montesquieu, précédé de César| publisher = Paris-Zanzibar| year = 1996| isbn = 2-911314-02-6}}
9. ^{{cite book| author = Сергей Нилус| title = Великое в малом и антихрист, как близкая политическая возможность. Записки православного.| location = Царское Село| year = 1905}}
10. ^{{cite journal| author = Philip Graves| title = The truth about "The Protocols"| journal = The Times |date=August 16–18, 1921| location = London| url = https://archive.org/details/truthaboutthepro00londiala}}
11. ^{{cite web | author =Kevin Schlottmann | title = Guide to the Bern Trial on the Protocols of the Elders of Zion Collection | website = Center for Jewish History | publisher = Leo Baeck Institute | date = July 17, 2013 | url = http://findingaids.cjh.org/?pID=477923#a23 | access-date = January 26, 2016 }}
12. ^{{cite book |author = Herman Bernstein |title = The Truth About "The Protocols of Zion". A Complete Exposure. |publisher=Covici Friede |location = New York |year = 1935 |isbn = 978-0870681769}}
13. ^{{Cite book | author =Alex Bein | year = 1990 | page = 339 |title = The Jewish question: biography of a world problem | isbn=978-0-8386-3252-9 | publisher = Fairleigh Dickinson Univ Press}}
14. ^{{Cite book | author1 = Steven Leonard Jacobs| author2 = Mark Weitzman| title = Dismantling the Big Lie: The Protocols of the Elders of Zion | year = 2003 | page = 15 | isbn = 0-88125-785-0}}
15. ^{{cite book | author = Cesare De Michelis| author-link = Cesare G. De Michelis|title = The Non-Existent Manuscript: a Study of the Protocols of the Sages of Zion, Studies in Antisemitism Series. |publisher = University of Nebraska Press |year = 2004 |isbn=0-8032-1727-7}}
16. ^{{cite book | author = Umberto Eco| author-link = Umberto Eco| title = Six Walks in the Fictional Woods| year = 1994| publisher = Harvard University Press| location = Cambridge, MA| isbn = 0-674-81050-3}}
17. ^{{cite book | author = Eugène Sue| author-link = Eugène Sue| title = Les Mystères du peuple ou Histoire d’une famille de prolétaires à travers les âges| publisher = Alphonse-Nicolas Lebègue| location = Bruxelles, 1849-1857}}