| Year | Orchestrator | Production |
|---|
2000
{{small|54th Tony Awards}} |
| Don Sebesky | Kiss Me, Kate |
| Doug Besterman | The Music Man |
| Jonathan Tunick | Marie Christine |
| Harold Wheeler | Swing! |
2001
{{small|55th Tony Awards}} |
| Doug Besterman | The Producers |
| Larry Hochman | A Class Act |
| Jonathan Tunick | Follies |
| Harold Wheeler | The Full Monty |
2002
{{small|56th Tony Awards}} |
| Doug Besterman & Ralph Burns | Thoroughly Modern Millie |
| Benny Andersson, Martin Koch & Björn Ulvaeus | Mamma Mia! |
| Bill Brohn | Sweet Smell of Success |
| Bruce Coughlin | Urinetown |
2003
{{small|57th Tony Awards}} |
| Billy Joel & Stuart Malina | Movin' Out |
| Nicholas Kitsopoulos | La bohème |
| Jonathan Tunick | Nine |
| Harold Wheeler | Hairspray |
2004
{{small|58th Tony Awards}} |
| Michael Starobin | Assassins |
| Paul Bogaev | Bombay Dreams |
| Bill Brohn | Wicked |
| Larry Hochman | Fiddler on the Roof |
2005
{{small|59th Tony Awards}} |
| Bruce Coughlin, Adam Guettel & Ted Sperling | The Light in the Piazza |
| Larry Hochman | Monty Python's Spamalot |
| Jonathan Tunick | Pacific Overtures |
| Harold Wheeler | Dirty Rotten Scoundrels |
2006
{{small|60th Tony Awards}} |
| Sarah Travis | The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |
| Larry Blank | The Drowsy Chaperone |
| Dick Lieb & Danny Troob | The Pajama Game |
| Steve Orich | Jersey Boys |
2007
{{small|61st Tony Awards}} |
| Duncan Sheik | Spring Awakening |
| Bruce Coughlin | Grey Gardens |
| Jonathan Tunick | LoveMusik |
| 110 in the Shade |
2008
{{small|62nd Tony Awards}} |
| Alex Lacamoire & Bill Sherman | In the Heights |
| Jason Carr | Sunday in the Park with George |
| Heidi Rodewald & Stew | Passing Strange |
| Jonathan Tunick | A Catered Affair |
2009
{{small|63rd Tony Awards}} |
| Martin Koch | Billy Elliot the Musical |
| Tom Kitt & Michael Starobin | Next to Normal |
| Larry Blank | White Christmas |
| John Clancy & Danny Troob | Shrek the Musical |
| Year | Orchestrator | Production |
|---|
2010
{{small|64th Tony Awards}} |
| David Bryan & Daryl Waters | Memphis |
| Jason Carr | La Cage aux Folles |
| Aaron Johnson | Fela! |
| Jonathan Tunick | Promises, Promises |
2011
{{small|65th Tony Awards}} |
| Larry Hochman & Stephen Oremus | The Book of Mormon |
| Doug Besterman | How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying |
| Larry Blank & Marc Shaiman | Catch Me If You Can |
| Larry Hochman | The Scottsboro Boys |
2012
{{small|66th Tony Awards}} |
| Martin Lowe | Once |
| Bill Brohn & Christopher Jahnke | Porgy and Bess |
| Bill Elliott | Nice Work If You Can Get It |
| Danny Troob | Newsies |
2013
{{small|67th Tony Awards}} |
| Stephen Oremus | Kinky Boots |
| Bryan Crook & Ethan Popp | The Musical |
| Chris Nightingale | Matilda the Musical |
| Danny Troob | Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella |
2014
{{small|68th Tony Awards}} |
| Jason Robert Brown | The Bridges of Madison County |
| Doug Besterman | Bullets Over Broadway |
| Steve Sidwell | The Carole King Musical |
| Jonathan Tunick | A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder |
2015
{{small|69th Tony Awards}} |
| Christopher Austin, Bill Elliott & Don Sebesky | An American in Paris |
| John Clancy | Fun Home |
| Larry Hochman | Something Rotten! |
| Rob Mathes | The Last Ship |
2016
{{small|70th Tony Awards}} |
| Alex Lacamoire | Hamilton |
| August Eriksmoen | Bright Star |
| Larry Hochman | She Loves Me |
| Daryl Waters | Shuffle Along |
2017
{{small|71st Tony Awards}} |
| Alex Lacamoire | Dear Evan Hansen |
| Bill Elliott & Greg Anthony Rassen | Bandstand |
| Larry Hochman | Hello, Dolly! |
| Dave Malloy | Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 |
2018
{{small|72nd Tony Awards}} |
| Jamshied Sharifi | The Band's Visit |
| John Clancy | Mean Girls |
| Tom Kitt | SpongeBob SquarePants |
| Annmarie Milazzo & Michael Starobin | Once on This Island |
| Jonathan Tunick | Carousel |