| 词条 | Who Were the Shudras? |
| 释义 |
Who Were the Shudras? is a history book published by Indian social reformer and polymath B. R. Ambedkar in 1946.[1][2] The book discusses the origin of the Shudra Varna. Ambedkar dedicated the book to Jyotirao Phule (1827–1890). Subject of the bookIn the book Ambedkar, citing Rigveda, Mahabharata and other ancient vedic scriptures, estimates that the Shudras were originally Aryans. They were a part of the Kshatriya Varna. Ambedkar writes in the preface of the book, "Undoubtedly the conclusions which I have reached as a result of my investigations. Two questions are raised in this book: (1) Who were the Shudras? and (2) How they came to be the fourth Varna of the Indo-Aryan society? My answers to them are summarised below.
Importantly, Ambedkar states that the Shudras of Hindu society are entirely different from Shudras of ancient Indo-Aryan Society. He writes, "...Such an inference is without any foundation, for the Shudras of the Indo-Aryan Society are absolutely different in race from the Shudras of the Hindu Society. The Shudras of the Hindu Society are not the racial descendants of the Shudras of the Indo-Aryan Society. This confusion has arisen because of the failure to realise that the meaning of the word 'Shudras' in the Indo-Aryan society is quite different from the meaning it has in the Hindu society. In the Indo-Aryans the word Shudra was proper name of one single people. It was the name of a people who belonged to a particular race. The word Shudra, as used in the Hindu society, is not a proper name at all. It is an epithet for a low uncultured class of people. It is a general cognomen of a miscellaneous and heterogeneous collection of tribes and groups, who have nothing in common except that they happen to be on a lower plane of culture. It is wrong to call them by the name Shudras. They have very little to do with their namesakes of the Aryan society, who had offended the Brahmins. It is a pity that these innocent and backward people of later days have been rolled up with the original Shudras and subjected to the same penalties for which they had given no cause."[4] Ambedkar also discusses Aryan race theory and Indo-Aryan migration theory in the book.[5] According to Arvind Sharma, Ambedkar noticed certain flaws in the Aryan invasion theory that were later acknowledged by western scholarship. For example, scholars now acknowledge anās in Rig Veda 5.29.10 refers to speech rather than the shape of the nose.[6] Ambedkar anticipated this modern view by stating: {{quote|The term Anasa occurs in Rig Veda V.29.10. What does the word mean? There are two interpretations. One is by Prof. Max Muller. The other is by Sayanacharya. According to Prof. Max Muller, it means 'one without nose' or 'one with a flat nose' and has as such been relied upon as a piece of evidence in support of the view that the Aryans were a separate race from the Dasyus. Sayanacharya says that it means 'mouthless,' i.e., devoid of good speech. This difference of meaning is due to difference in the correct reading of the word Anasa. Sayanacharya reads it as an-asa while Prof. Max Muller reads it as a-nasa. As read by Prof. Max Muller, it means 'without nose.' Question is : which of the two readings is the correct one? There is no reason to hold that Sayana's reading is wrong. On the other hand there is everything to suggest that it is right. In the first place, it does not make non-sense of the word. Secondly, as there is no other place where the Dasyus are described as noseless, there is no reason why the word should be read in such a manner as to give it an altogether new sense. It is only fair to read it as a synonym of Mridhravak. There is therefore no evidence in support of the conclusion that the Dasyus belonged to a different race.[6]}}ContentsPreface Part I
Part II
See also
References1. ^{{cite book|last1=Dr. B.R. Ambedkar|first1=|title=Who were the Shudras?|date=1949|publisher=Thackers|location=Bombay}} 2. ^{{citation|last1=Karmarkar|first1=A.P.|title=Review: Who were the Shudras? by Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar|date=1946|journal=Annals of the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute |volume=30 |issue=1-2 |pages=158–160 |jstor=41784527}} 3. ^http://www.ambedkar.org/ambcd/38A.%20Who%20were%20the%20Shudras%20Preface.htm#PRE 4. ^http://www.ambedkar.org/ambcd/38C2.%20Who%20were%20the%20Shudras%20PART%20II.htm#a11 5. ^http://www.ambedkar.org/ambcd/38B2.%20Who%20were%20the%20Shudras%20PART%20I.htm#a04 6. ^1 {{cite journal|ref=Sharma|author=Sharma, Arvind |title=Dr. B. R. Ambedkar on the Aryan Invasion and the Emergence of the Caste System in India|journal= Journal of the American Academy of Religion|year= 2005|volume= 73 |issue=3|pages=849|jstor=4139922 |doi=10.1093/jaarel/lfi081}} Further reading
External links
5 : Books about civilizations|Books by B. R. Ambedkar|Dalit literature|Dalit history|1946 books |
| 随便看 |
|
开放百科全书收录14589846条英语、德语、日语等多语种百科知识，基本涵盖了大多数领域的百科知识，是一部内容自由、开放的电子版国际百科全书。