| # | Wrestler | Reign | Date | Length | Location | Notes | | 1 | Simon Davis | 1 | 1993|12|27}} | month1=12|day1=27|year1=1993|month2=11|day2=16|year2=1995}} | New York | Defeated Sonic Johnson to become the first champion |
| 2 | Baller | 1 | 1995|11|16}} | month1=11|day1=16|year1=1995|month2=02|day2=22|year2=1996}} | Boston, Mass |
| 3 | Aka-San | 1 | 1996|02|22}} | month1=02|day1=22|year1=1996|month2=08|day2=27|year2=1998}} | Atlantic City, New Jersey | This was a ladder match |
| 4 | John Rambo | 1 | 1998|08|27}} | month1=08|day1=27|year1=1998|month2=03|day2=01|year2=1999}} | Harrisburg, Pennsylvania | This was a ladder match |
| — | Vacated | — | 1999|03}} | — | — | The WSWF became World Xtreme Wrestling in November 1998. John Rambo was stripped of the title in March 1999 due to failure to defend the title within 30 days |
| 5 | Samu | 1 | 1999|04|24}} | month1=04|day1=24|year1=1999|month2=09|day2=19|year2=1999}} | Mountainville, Pennsylvania | Defeated The Mad Russian to win the vacant title |
| 6 | Simon Davis | 2 | 1999|09|19}} | month1=09|day1=19|year1=1999|month2=10|day2=06|year2=1999}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania |
| 7 | | {{small>(formerly Jake Molsonn)}}2 | 1999|10|06}} | month1=10|day1=06|year1=1999|month2=10|day2=30|year2=1999}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania |
| 8 | Jak Molsonn | 2 | 1999|10|30}} | month1=10|day1=30|year1=1999|month2=01|day2=14|year2=2000}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania | Defeated Oxx Hogg (subbing for Jake Daniels) and The Hungarian Barbarian in a three–way match |
| 9 | Chicago Heat | 1 | 2000|01|14}} | month1=01|day1=14|year1=2000|month2=01|day2=22|year2=2000}} | Plymouth, Pennsylvania |
| 10 | Jak Molsonn | 3 | 2000|01|22}} | month1=01|day1=22|year1=2000|month2=02|day2=19|year2=2000}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania |
| 11 | Sugaa | 1 | 2000|02|19}} | month1=02|day1=19|year1=2000|month2=06|day2=02|year2=2000}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania | Defeated Jak Molsonn, The Inferno Kid and L.A. Smooth in a fatal four–way match ladder match |
| 12 | Shane Black | 1 | 2000|06|02}} | month1=06|day1=02|year1=2000|month2=06|day2=03|year2=2000}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania | Sugaa's WXW Cruiserweight Championship was also on the line in this match. Shane Black became the first person to hold both WXW Cruiserweight and WXW World Heavyweight Championships |
| — | Held up | — | 2000|06|03}} | — | — | Both titles were immediately held up due to a controversial ending of the match |
| 13 | Sugaa | 2 | 2000|06|03}} | month1=06|day1=03|year1=2000|month2=09|day2=16|year2=2000}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania | Sugaa defeated Shane Black to win both titles. Sugaa held the Cruiserweight title until July 6, when he exceeded the cruiserweight division weight limit |
| 14 | Salvatore Bellomo | 1 | 2000|09|16}} | month1=09|day1=16|year1=2000|month2=01|day2=09|year2=2001}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania | Defeated Sugaa and The Hungarian Barbarian in a three–way match |
| 15 | Samu | 2 | 2001|01|09}} | month1=01|day1=09|year1=2001|month2=05|day2=27|year2=2001}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 16 | Dylan Dean | 1 | 2001|05|27}} | month1=05|day1=27|year1=2001|month2=06|day2=17|year2=2001}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 17 | Metal Maniac | 1 | 2001|06|17}} | month1=06|day1=17|year1=2001|month2=06|day2=17|year2=2001}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania | Awarded the title by Dylan Dean |
| 18 | Samu | 3 | 2001|06|17}} | month1=06|day1=17|year1=2001|month2=10|day2=21|year2=2001}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| — | Vacated | N/A | 2001|10|21}} | — | Allentown, Pennsylvania | Samu was stripped of the title by WXW Commissioner Lotto Money |
| 19 | Dylan Dean | 2 | 2001|10|21}} | month1=10|day1=21|year1=2001|month2=10|day2=21|year2=2001}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania | WXW Commissioner Lotto Money returned the title to Dean, because he was never defeated for it |
| 20 | Samu | 4 | 2001|10|21}} | month1=10|day1=21|year1=2001|month2=03|day2=02|year2=2002}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 21 | Sugaa | 3 | 2002|03|02}} | month1=03|day1=02|year1=2002|month2=06|day2=22|year2=2002}} | Hazleton, Pennsylvania | This was a fans bring the weapons match |
| 22 | Afa, Jr. | 1 | 2002|06|22}} | month1=06|day1=22|year1=2002|month2=07|day2=11|year2=2003}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| — | Vacated | N/A | 2003|07|11}} | — | Afa, Jr. vacated the title to leave WXW and attend college |
| 23 | Billy Dream | 1 | 2003|07|11}} | month1=07|day1=11|year1=2003|month2=10|day2=19|year2=2003}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania | Won a battle royal, by last eliminating Mana the Polynesian Warrior to win the vacant title |
| 24 | Gene Snitsky | 1 | 2003|10|19}} | month1=10|day1=19|year1=2003|month2=03|day2=28|year2=2004}} | Sciota, Pennsylvania | This was a last man standing match |
| 25 | Mana the Polynesian Warrior | 1 | 2004|03|28}} | month1=03|day1=28|year1=2004|month2=05|day2=29|year2=2004}} | Mountainville, Pennsylvania |
| 26 | Rapid Fire Maldonado | 1 | 2004|05|29}} | month1=05|day1=29|year1=2004|month2=07|day2=09|year2=2004}} | Sciota, Pennsylvania |
| 27 | Mana the Polynesian Warrior | 2 | 2004|07|09}} | month1=07|day1=09|year1=2004|month2=10|day2=29|year2=2004}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 28 | Sinister X | 1 | 2004|10|29}} | month1=10|day1=29|year1=2004|month2=11|day2=24|year2=2004}} | Sciota, Pennsylvania | Sinister X defeated Mana the Polynesian Warrior and L.A. Smooth in a three–way match |
| 29 | Jeff Coleman | 1 | 2004|11|21}} | month1=11|day1=21|year1=2004|month2=02|day2=20|year2=2005}} | Sciota, Pennsylvania |
| — | Vacated | N/A | 2005|02|20}} | — | — | Jeff Coleman was stripped of the title, due to failure to defend within 30 days due to injury |
| 30 | Johnny Bravado | 1 | 2005|02|27}} | month1=02|day1=27|year1=2005|month2=05|day2=29|year2=2005}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania | This was a "whirlwind" match |
| 31 | Rockin' Rebel | 1 | 2005|05|29}} | month1=05|day1=29|year1=2005|month2=07|day2=08|year2=2005}} | Bushkill, Pennsylvania |
| 32 | Johnny Bravado | 2 | 2005|07|08}} | month1=07|day1=08|year1=2005|month2=11|day2=12|year2=2005}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 33 | Havoc | 1 | 2005|11|12}} | month1=11|day1=12|year1=2005|month2=03|day2=09|year2=2006}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 34 | Samu | 5 | 2006|03|09}} | month1=03|day1=09|year1=2006|month2=04|day2=15|year2=2007}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 35 | Rage | 1 | 2007|04|15}} | month1=04|day1=15|year1=2007|month2=06|day2=02|year2=2007}} | Allentown, Pennsylvania |
| 36 | Samu | 6 | 2007|06|02}} | — | Pennsylvania |
| 37 | Sugaa | 4 | 2008}} | — | Minneola, Florida |
| 38 | Dylan Night | 1 | 2009|09|26}} | month1=09|day1=26|year1=2009|month2=01|day2=30|year2=2010}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 39 | Sugaa | 5 | 2010|01|30}} | month1=01|day1=30|year1=2010|month2=02|day2=20|year2=2010}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 40 | Dylan Night | 2 | 2010|02|20}} | month1=02|day1=20|year1=2010|month2=05|day2=01|year2=2010}} | Minneola, Florida | Dylan Night defeated Sugaa in the first ever Loser Leaves WXW Last Man Standing match to win the title |
| 41 | Nick Nero | 1 | 2010|05|01}} | month1=05|day1=01|year1=2010|month2=05|day2=22|year2=2010}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 42 | The Perfect Creation | 1 | 2010|05|22}} | month1=05|day1=22|year1=2010|month2=09|day2=11|year2=2010}} | Minneola, Florida | The Perfect Creation defeated Nick Nero and CJ O'Doyle in a three–way match |
| 43 | Mark Silva | 1 | 2010|09|11}} | month1=09|day1=11|year1=2010|month2=10|day2=23|year2=2010}} | Minneola, Florida | Mark Silva defeated The Perfect Creation and Nick Folie in a three–way match |
| 44 | The Perfect Creation | 2 | 2010|10|23}} | month1=10|day1=23|year1=2010|month2=01|day2=15|year2=2011}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 45 | Dylan Night | 3 | 2011|01|15}} | month1=01|day1=15|year1=2011|month2=02|day2=12|year2=2011}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 46 | Mark Silva | 2 | 2011|02|12}} | month1=02|day1=12|year1=2011|month2=12|day2=17|year2=2011}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 47 | Bryan Maddox | 1 | 2011|12|17}} | month1=12|day1=17|year1=2011|month2=06|day2=16|year2=2012}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 48 | Sean Maluta | 1 | 2012|06|16}} | month1=06|day1=16|year1=2012|month2=01|day2=26|year2=2013}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 49 | Bryan Maddox | 2 | 2013|01|26}} | month1=01|day1=26|year1=2013|month2=05|day2=11|year2=2013}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 50 | Nick Nero | 1 | 2013|05|11}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 51 | Bryan Maddox | 1 | 2013}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 52 | Noah Kekoa | 1 | 2013|09}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 53 | Sean Maluta | 2 | 2014|05|09}} | month1=05|day1=09|year1=2014|month2=08|day2=23|year2=2014}} | Minneola, Florida |
| — | Vacated | — | 2014|08|23}} | — |
| 54 | Mark Silva | 3 | 2014|12|20}} | month1=12|day1=20|year1=2014|month2=01|day2=30|year2=2015}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 55 | Sugaa | 6 | 2015|01|31}} | month1=01|day1=31|year1=2015|month2=04|day2=12|year2=2015}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 56 | Irish Jack | 1 | 2015|04|12}} | month1=04|day1=12|year1=2015|month2=07|day2=11|year2=2015}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 57 | Mr. NYR | 1 | 2015|07|11}} | month1=07|day1=11|year1=2015|month2=07|day2=11|year2=2015}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 58 | ERA | 1 | 2015|07|11}} | month1=07|day1=11|year1=2015|month2=11|day2=07|year2=2015}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 59 | Jaxen Blade | 1 | 2015|11|07}} | month1=11|day1=07|year1=2015|month2=07|day2=30|year2=2016}} | Minneola, Florida |
| 60 | Sean Maluta | 3 | 2016|07|30}} | month1=07|day1=30|year1=2016}}+ | Minneola, Florida |
As of {{CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{CURRENTDAY}}, {{CURRENTYEAR}}.
1. ^http://www.cagematch.net/?id=5&nr=692
2. ^http://wxwwrestling.homestead.com/HistoryTitles.html