| Category | Gold Winner | Silver Winner | | Best Cover Art | Five Fingers, Port of Deceit by Privateer Press | Hollow Earth Expedition by Exile Games Studio |
| Best Interior Art | M&M Ultimate Power by Green Ronin Publishing | Qin by Seventh Circle Company |
| Best Production Values | Ptolus, City by the Spire by Malhavoc Press/White Wolf | M&M Ultimate Power by Green Ronin Publishing |
| Best Writing | Five Fingers, Port of Deceit by Privateer Press | WFRP Children of the Horned Rat by Black Industries |
| Best Rules | M&M Ultimate Power by Green Ronin | Spirit of the Century by Evil Hat Productions |
| Best Cartography | Ptolus, City by the Spire by Malhavoc Press | WFRP GM Toolkit by Black Industries |
| Best Miniature Product | Game Mastery: Flip-mat Tavern by Paizo Publishing | EZ Dungeons by Fat Dragon Games |
| Best Adventure | WFRP: Lure of the Liche Lord by Black Industries | M&M Time of Vengeance by Green Ronin Publishing |
| Best Regalia | Order of the Stick, No Cure for the Paladin Blues by Giant in the Playground | Liber Chaotica by Black Library |
| Best Setting | Ptolus, City by the Spire by Malhavoc Press/White Wolf | Five Fingers, Port of Deceit by Privateer Press |
| Best Supplement | WFRP Companion by Black Industries | M&M Ultimate Powe, by Green Ronin Publishing |
| Best Aid or Accessory | Deck of Many Things by Green Ronin Publishing | GameMastery Combat Pad by Open Mind Games/Paizo |
| Best Fan Site | Dragonlance Nexus | Planewalker |
| Best Podcast | Have Games, Will Travel | Yog Radio |
| Best Free Product or Web-Enhancement | Savage Tide Player's Guide by Paizo Publishing | Classic Battletech Free Package by Catalyst Games |
| Best Electronic Book | Classic Battletech Free Package by Catalyst Games | Magical Medieval Society: European Warfare by Expeditious Retreat Press |
| Best Game | Scion, Hero by White Wolf Publishing | Qin by Seventh Circle Company |
| Best d20/OGL Product | Mutants and Masterminds, Ultimate Power by Green Ronin Publishing | Five Fingers, Port of Deceit by Privateer Press |
| Product of the Year | Ptolus, City by the Spire by Malhavoc Press/White Wolf | WFRP, Children of the Horned Rat by Black Industries |
| Fan's Choice Best Publisher | Wizards of the Coast | Green Ronin Publishing |