| Year | Player Name | Position | High School |
|---|
| 1992 | Preston|Wilson}} | OF/RHP | Bamberg-Ehrhardt High School |
| 1993 | Trot|Nixon}} | OF/LHP | New Hanover High School |
| 1994 | Doug|Million}} | LHP | Sarasota High School |
| 1995 | Ben|Davis|dab=baseball}} | C | Malvern Preparatory School |
| 1996 | Matt|White|dab=minor league pitcher}} | RHP | Waynesboro Area High School |
| 1997 | Darnell|McDonald}} | OF | Cherry Creek High School |
| 1998 | Drew|Henson}} | 3B/RHP | Brighton High School |
| 1999 | Josh|Hamilton}} | OF/LHP | Athens Drive High School |
| 2000 | Matt|Harrington}} | P | Palmdale High School |
| 2001 | Joe|Mauer}} | C | Cretin-Derham Hall High School |
| 2002 | Scott|Kazmir}} | LHP | Cypress Falls High School |
| 2003 | Jeff|Allison}} | RHP | Peabody Veterans Memorial High School |
| 2004 | Homer|Bailey}} | RHP | La Grange High School |
| 2005 | Justin|Upton}} | SS | Great Bridge High School |
| 2006 | Adrian|Cardenas}} | SS/2B | Monsignor Edward Pace High School |
| 2007 | Mike|Moustakas}} | SS | Chatsworth High School |
| 2008 | Ethan|Martin}} | RHP/3B | Stephens County High School |
| 2009 | Bryce|Harper}} | C | Las Vegas High School |
| 2010 | Kaleb|Cowart}} | 3B/RHP | Cook County High School |
| 2011 | Dylan|Bundy}} | RHP | Owasso High School |
| 2012 | Byron|Buxton}} | OF | Appling County High School |
| 2013 | Clint|Frazier}} | OF | Loganville High School |
| 2014 | Alex|Jackson|dab=baseball}} | C | Rancho Bernardo High School |
| 2015 | Kyle|Tucker}} | OF | Plant High School |
| 2016 | Mickey Moniak | OF | La Costa Canyon High School |
| 2017 | MacKenzie Gore | LHP | Whiteville High School |
| 2018 | Cole Winn | RHP | Orange Lutheran High School |