In 1925, about 70% of Presbyterian churches across Canada joined the new United Church of Canada, although the split in Toronto was closer to 50-50. This is a list of churches within the present boundaries of Toronto that have been part of The Presbyterian Church in Canada since June 1925.
In 1963, St. Andrew's in Hamilton Bermuda was added to West Toronto, and the congregations west of Toronto and York County boundaries were dismissed to Brampton Presbytery a couple of years later.
| Congregation (Active are in bold) | Location | Dates | Notes | Image |
|---|
| Albion Gardens | Thistletown | 1957-2012 | Building constructed in 1961. In July 2011, merged with Pine Ridge PC, and became Fellowship Presbyterian in April 2012. |
| Armour Heights | Armour Heights | 1950 | Extension congregation, merged in 1998 with former Melrose Park congregation. |
| Beaches | The Beaches | 1925 | Minority Group from Kew Beach (now Beach United). |
| Bonar | St Clarens Ave., (w. side) n. of College near Lansdowne | 1889–1969 | Named after Scottish brothers Andrew and Horatius Bonar. Buildings constructed in 1907 and 1922; demolished c1970. Merged with Parkdale Presbyterian Church to form Bonar-Parkdale |
| Bonar-Parkdale | Parkdale | 1969 | Formed in 1969 as a merger of Parkdale Presbyterian Church and Bonar Presbyterian Church. Bonar Parkdale Place constructed in the 1990s. |
| Bridlewood | L'Amoreaux | 1967 | Daughter congregation of Knox Toronto; self-supporting in under one year. Building constructed in 1973; 1984 addition contained many furninshings from former Cooke's Church. |
| Calvin | Deer Park | 1925 | Minority Group, mainly from Deer Park, and also from Avenue Road. Now, Deer Park uses this building and regularly shares services. |
| Celebration | Glen Park | 2003 | Merger of Coldstream (1950) and Fairbank (1890; 1925 Minority from Fairbank Presbyterian / St. Cuthbert's United) on Coldstream site. |
| Chalmers | Dundas and Dovecourt | 1877-1978. | Originally named Brockton Presbyterian. Building constructed 1889. Fire in 1945 destroyed Sanctuary, Sunday School hall renovated as replacement. Merged with St. Paul's Dovercourt, Demolished in the early 1980s. |
| Chinese | Grange Park | Congregation started in 1912; group went to United Church in 1925 | Building constructed in 1960, replacing former building expropriated for Toronto City Hall. |
| Chinese Agincourt Mission | Agincourt | 1979-1991 | This group met at Knox Presbyterian Agincourt following the arrival of many Chinese families in the area. Prior to the erection of the Presbytery of Pickering in 1990, this group became a formal congregation. In 1991, Markham Chinese Presbyterian Church was dedicated on Dennison Street in the Milliken community, and in 1992 joined Oak Ridges Presbytery. |
| Clairlea Park | Clairlea | 1952 | York Townline Cemetery and former Chalmers Canada Presbyterian Church 1863-1890 at NE corner of Pharmacy and St. Clair; land swap for cemetery (all but one re-interred at Pine Hills Cemetery). Gas Station (now demolished) on old site; Church is one block east |
| Coldstream | Glen Park | 1949-2003 | Congregation started in 1949, building on Bathurst Street in 1951. Joined with Fairbank in 2004, becoming Celebration. |
| Cooke's | Queen and Mutual | 1851–1982 | Previously known as Second Presbyterian, and named after Irish Presbyterian leader. Demolished 1984 |
| Cowan Avenue | Parkdale | 1886-1928 |
| Dale | 1884–1939 | Mission of St. Andrew's Church started in the 1870s. Known as St. Mark's until move in 1909. Previously located at Adelaide West of Tecumseh, and in 1886 to King and Tecumseh. Congregation closed in 1939. Building is now St. Nicholas Ukrainian Catholic Church. |
| Davenport | Davenport | 1904–1972 | Buildings constructed in 1905, 1909, and renovation in 1921. Merged with Wychwood Presbyterian to form Wychwood-Davenport on the Wychwood site. Building continues as Galilee Korean Presbyterian Church (Han-Ca East Presbytery, Presbyterian Church in Canada) |
| Deer Park | Deer Park | 1887–1925 | Began as a mission near Yonge Street and St. Clair Avenue West. New building 1911 near St. Clair West and Avenue Road. Congregation voted in 1925 to join United Church. Dissidents started nearby Calvin Church. Remnant of Deer Park United congregation moved to Calvin in 2008. Building desanctified and sold to a developer. |
| Dovercourt Road | Dufferin Grove | 1886–1968 | Originally met as Mission of Chalmers Church, located north of Bloor and Dovercourt. Present building constructed at Hepbourne and Dovercourt in 1905. Merged with St. Paul's Presbyterian in 1968 to form Dovercourt-St. Paul's, then with Dufferin Street in 1993 to become St. Paul's . Presently used by Portuguese-Speaking Presbyterian Church. |
| Dovercourt-St. Paul's | Dufferin Grove | 1968–1993 | Created from merger of Dovercourt Presbyterian and St. Paul's in 1968. In 1993 merged with Dufferin Street Presbyterian to become St. Paul's Presbyterian, and closed in 2005. |
| Dufferin Street | Wallace-Emerson | 1907–1993 | Merged with Dovercourt-St. Paul's Presbyterian Church to form St. Paul's Presbyterian in 1993. Building sold to a Baptist ministry, and was sold to become lofts in 2012. |
| East Toronto Korean | Little Korea | 1975-2005 | started after Toronto Korean's move into the former Davenport building, this group started in Scarborough's Wexford building, moved to Roger's Memorial in 1977, then acquired former Epworth United on Christie Street in an area where Korean-Canadian businesses opened many shops and restaurants. In 2005, the congregation moved into new facilities in Vaughan, and renamed themselves Vaughan Community Presbyterian Church. |
| Emmanuel | Upper Beaches | 1885–1988 | Started as East Toronto Junction Presbyterian Mission in 1885. First building located on Main Street. Became Emmanuel with merger of Chalmers, York Townline congregation in Scarborough Township, and maintenance of Cemetery in 1893. Led by Rev. Dr. Thomas Rogers for 30 years, and who was active in Presbyterian Church Association (1925 anti-Union vote), as well as seeing other congregations begin in district; including Rogers Memorial. In 1987, merged with two "daughter" congregations to form Faith Community Presbyterian in the former St. James building. |
| Fairbank | Fairbank | 1925-2003 | A "Minority Group" from Fairbank (later St. Cuthburt's United) Presbyterian. Joined by Mount Dennis in 1939. Merged into Coldstream in 2003, becoming Celebration. Building now used by African congregation. |
| Faith Community Presbyterian | Old East York | 1988 | Created as a merger of three congregations, St. James, Emmanuel, and St. Matthew's in the former St. James building. |
| Fallingbrook | Birch Cliff | 1948 |
| Fellowship | Thistletown | 2012 | Consummation of the 2011 merger of Albion Gardens and Pine Ridge congregations, meeting in the Albion Gardens building. |
| First Hungarian | Humewood-Cedarvale | 1930 | 1967 move from 206 McCaul Street (1938 Building), and merged with Oshawa Hungarian Mission in 1970; services are still held monthly in Oshawa. 1948 building built as home of Willowdale's Wellspring Worship Centre (formerly Banfield Memorial Evangelical Missionary Church). |
| Forest Hill | pre-1925-1935 |
| Gateway Community | Flemingdon Park | 1970-2010 | In same building as Blessed John XXIII Roman Catholic; Congregation dissolved 2010; now a Mission. |
| Ghanaian | 1995 | Joint Congregation of Presbyterian Church of Ghana and Presbyterian Church in Canada. Congregation constructed building at Highway 400 and Finch in 2003 but moved to Finch and Signet Drive 2006. Services in English, Ga, and Twi. |
| Glebe | Davisville | 1912 | mission of Bloor Street Presbyterian. Remained in Presbyterian Church after voting twice in 1925—Ballot Box went on fire when first count taken. Closed in Jan 2013 and merged with Leaside. |
| Glenview | North Toronto | 1925 | formed as Minority Group from Eglinton Presbyterian (St. George's United Church, now Eglinton-St. George's United) and Bedford Park. |
| Grace, Etobicoke | Centennial | 1955–2002 | Originally called Bloorview, renamed Grace following acquisition of land in different neighbourhood. Building constructed in 1961, expanded in 1985. Merged with Hillview Presbyterian to form Graceview in the Grace Building in 2002. |
| Grace, West Hill | West Hill | 1956 | merger of Centennial Road and West Rouge Sunday Schools. Built in Pickering Township, before West Rouge joined Scarborough in 1973. |
| Graceview | Centennial | 2002 | merger of Grace Presbyterian Church (Etobicoke, Ontario) and Hillview Presbyterian Church in former Grace Building. |
| Guildwood Community | Guildwood | 1960 |
| High Park | 1925–1968 | Minority group of Alhambra and High Park. Site was a former School. Merged with Morningside to form Morningside High Park. Building is now Jami Mosque. |
| Hillview | Centennial | 1955–2002 | In 2002 merged with Grace Presbyterian to form Graceview. Building is now home of St. Timothy's Korean Presbyterian Church (Han-Ca East Presbytery, Presbyterian Church in Canada) |
| Iona | Don Valley Village | 1966 | In same building as St. Cyprian Anglican Church; was originally part of the "Tri-Congregations" with St. Cyprian and the former Hillcrest United Church. |
| Kingsway | Kingsway | 1945-1961 | congregation started as post WWII work in June 1945. Congregation established in 1946, and acquired Montgomery's Inn, expanding facilities in 1952. Following resignation of founding minister to health concerns a decade later, supply ministers conducted Sunday services, until merger with nearby St. Giles Humber Valley in January 1961. Montgomery's Inn is now a Toronto City Museum |
| Knox, Toronto (Spadina Ave.) | Harbord Village | 1843 (from 1820) | Moved in 1905 from Yonge and Queen (Still owned by Knox Church, Currently leased to Hudson Bay Company), Sanctuary completed 1909. First congregation started as First Presbyterian Congregation of York, which was the first Presbyterian Church established in York, the old name of Toronto. Named after John Knox. |
| Knox, Agincourt | Agincourt | 1925 | Minority group of Knox Presbyterian Church, Agincourt (now Knox United) |
| Leaside | Leaside | 1942 | Formed originally as extension of Glebe Congregation. First Minister Rev. Dr. J. Charles Hay, later Principal of Knox College. When Glebe closed in 2013, Leaside merged with Glebe, keeping Leaside name and site. |
| Logan Geggie Memorial | 1950-1984 | Sunday School started in 1947 from Parkdale, congregation named after a former esteemed Minister of Parkdale who died in that pulpit in 1922. Congregation became two-point charge with Park Lawn in 1989 until they merged into Mimico in 1995. Building sold to Buddhist group. |
| Malvern | Malvern | 1975. | Originallya shared building with Anglican Church, who left in the early 2000s. |
| Melrose Park | North Toronto | 1930s | A dissenting group from Glenview Church formed itself into this congregation which met at 250 Fairlawn Avenue until its amalgamation into Armour Heights Church in the late 1990s. The building was demolished, and replaced with housing. |
| Melville | West Hill | 1852 | Started as Knox College Student Mission, joined with Knox Agincourt until 1883, Dunbarton (Pickering) until 1900, when it became a single-point charge. |
| Mimico | Mimico | 1925 | Reacquired their 1890 building from United Church, who went into Wesley Methodist building. New Sanctuary built in 1950s beside old building, since renovated into hall. |
| Morningside | Swansea | 1889–1968 | Merged with High Park to form Morningside High Park. Named after Morningside Church in Edinburgh. |
| Morningside High Park | Swansea | 1968 | Created from a merger of Morningside Presbyterian and High Park Presbyterian; High Park's organ was brought over at merger. |
| Mount Dennis | Mount Dennis | 1925-1945 | Minority group from Mount Dennis (once Chalmers' United before merging into Mount Dennis United) that eventually merged into Fairbank. Building on Weston Road north of Eglinton demolished. |
| North Park | Maple Leaf | 1950s | congregation now a Spanish-speaking mission, and building is for sale. |
| Oakwood Presbyterian Church | Oakwood-Vaughan | 1911–1977 | Dissolved 1977, Building bought by Mount Zion Apolstolic Church, who moved to Malton in 1999, building razed 2009. |
| Olivet | Yorkville | 1925–1969 | Minority group from Westminster, Bloor Street, Old St. Andrew's and St James Square acquired former Olivet Congregational Church.Named Central Presbyterian until 1935 and then Avenue Road Presbyterian until 1947. Closed 1977. Building is now commercial. |
| Park Lawn | 1952-1994 | Congregation formally erected in 1953, and building constructed in 1956. came two-point charge with Logan Geggie in the late 1980s, and amalgamed into Mimico in 1994. Building was demolished afterwards. |
| Parkdale | Parkdale | 1879–1969 | Merged with Bonar Presbyterian in 1969 to form Bonar-Parkdale. Had merged with Cowan Avenue PC in 1928 (that had grown out of Parkdale in 1886) |
| Patterson | Earlscourt | 1925–2011 | Minority group of St. David's United, initially called St. David's Continuing Presbyterian Church. Name changed in 1927 to avoid coal deliveries going to wrong building, named after longtime minister of Cookes Church, Toronto. Congregation dissolved in November 2011. |
| Pine Ridge | Humber Summit | 1953-2012 | Originally, an extension of Woodbridge Presbyterian Church. Was joined with Rexdale for 20 years. On June 19, 2011, congregation held final service, prior to merging with Albion Gardens. |
| Portuguese Speaking | Dufferin Grove | 1985 | Housed in former St. Paul's Presbyterian, that they acquired in 2005. |
| Queen Street East | Leslieville | 1877 | Originally called Leslieville Presbyterian Church, name changed upon Leslieville joining Toronto in 1893. Survived major fire in the late 1960s. |
| Rexdale | Rexdale | 1956 | Seniors Housing complex opened in 1979; |
| Riverdale | Riverdale | 1908 | original building now being used, as 1912 Sanctuary is now lofts. |
| Rogers Memorial | East Danforth | 1922–2000 | Closed in 2000, today building is home to Toronto Chinese Mennonite Church |
| Rosedale | Rosedale | 1907 | First unit (small sanctuary) built in 1908, second unit in the 1950s with church Hall. Land for originally-planned larger sanctuary was expropriated when Mount Pleasant Road was opened up in the 1950s. |
| Royce | 1904–1969 | Alhambra withdrew in the 1910s; Royce Avenue rebuilt and remained in PCC in 1925. Merged with Victoria Presbyterian to form Victoria-Royce Presbyterian building demolished in 1970 at Dupont (formerly Royce Avenue) and Perth. |
| Runnymede | Runnymede | 1906 | original building moved from St John's Road to site in 1912; present building 1950 (original on parking lot) |
| St. Andrew's (King Street) | Downtown | 1830 | Met on Church Street until present building opened 1876; major redevelopment in the 1990s, and 48th Highlanders Museum in building. |
| St. Andrew's Humber Heights | Humber Heights-Westmount | 1949 |
| St. Andrew's Islington | Islington-Six Points | 1922 | building rebuilt 1951; sanctuary reversed and Hall built 1968. |
| St. Andrew's, Scarborough | Bendale | 1818 | Present building constructed 1849; dedicated 1850. Hall constructed 1957. Oldest Presbyterian Congregation in Toronto, started by Thomson family; active cemetery contains most of Scarborough pioneer European families. Was originally called Presbyterian Church of Scarboro in connection with the (Established) Church of Canada. Renamed St. Andrew's after 1875. Accessibility Ramp dedicated by Lieutenant Governor David Onley at 190th Anniversary in June 2008. |
| St. David's | Eglinton East | 1952 | Started as Kitchener Park Extension mission, renamed St. David's in 1955. St. David's Place opened in 1978. |
| St. Giles | The Kingsway | 1951 |
| St. Giles Kingsway | The Kingsway | 1961. | 1961 Merger of St. Giles and Kingsway (1940s), the latter using Montgomery's Inn. Original St. Giles sanctuary recently renovated for a contemporary worship service called "The Well". |
| St. James | 1925–1988 | Originally named MacPherson (Continuing) to 1939 (MacPherson United changed name to Dentonia Park). Merged with two other congregations (Emmanuel and St. Matthew's) to form Faith Community Presbyterian in St. James building. |
| St. James, Long Branch | Long Branch | 1914–2001 | Originally called Dunn Memorial; renamed in the 1950s when Sanctuary built. Now home of a Korean Presbyterian (not PCC) congregation. |
| St. John's | Riverside South | 1888 | Sanctuary dedicated in 1907 (moved from Gerrard East and Bolton). Basement home to National Presbyterian Museum since 2002. |
| St. John's Milliken | Milliken | 1980 | Name "recycled" from former St. John's Milliken in Markham Township (1864–1929). Shares building with Anglican congregation. |
| St. Mark's | Don Mills | 1952 | Shares building with Myung Sung Korean Presbyterian Church (Han Ca East Presbytery, PCC). Hall, including original building was replaced by Apartment complex in the 1990s. |
| St. Matthew's | 1925–1988 | Minority group from Rhodes Avenue. Building constructed in 1948. Merged with two other (Emmanuel, St James) congregations to form Faith Presbyterian. Building now used by Toronto Formosan Presbyterian Church, a PCC Congregation of Taiwanese-Canadians. |
| St. Paul's Presbyterian Church (old) | Seaton Village | 1887–1968 | In 1914, Erskine PC (1838 as First United Presbyterian, then Bay Street Canada Presbyterian Church) joined congregation. Merged with Dovercourt Presbyterian to form Dovercourt-St Paul's Presbyterian, building demolished, apartments on site. |
| St. Paul's Presbyterian Church (new) | Dufferin Grove | 1993–2005 | Created from merger of Dovercourt-St Paul's Presbyterian with Dufferin Presbyterian. Building now home to Portuguese-speaking Presbyterian congregation. |
| St. Stephen's, Scarborough | Woburn | 1958 | Started as Golf Club Road Presbyterian Church, later named St. Stephen's. Building constructed and dedicated in 1962. |
| St. Stephen's, Weston | Emery | 1960 | Congregation started in local school. Building constructed in 1965. |
| St. Timothy's |
| Toronto Formosan | Little India | 1980 | Congregation started with Taiwanese Presbyterians, many whose ancestors became Christians through PCC Missionaries led by George Leslie Mackay. Moved into former St. Matthew's (see above) in 1989. 2 Taiwanese groups (Central and Toronto Formosan) merged in 2009. |
| Toronto Korean | 1969 | Originally met in Knox, Spadina. Services later held at former Olivet in Yorkville, before former Davenport Presbyterian Church acquired. 1997 saw move to new facilities in Don Mills, in close proximity to major expressways. |
| Trinity Mandarin | Don Valley Village | 1992; | Originally met in Leslieville, and for many years at Willowdale Presbyterian. In same building as Iona Presbyterian and St. Cyprian Anglican Church |
| Trinity York Mills | York Mills | 1953 | York Mills designation provides continuity with York Mills PC (1835–1886). Large Sanctuary built in the early 1990s. |
| Ukrainian | 1929-1976 | Mission started after arrival of Rev. Michael Fesenko from Princeton Seminary. Conducted meetings on streets and in Dale Church. Following Dale's closure, small building on nearby Claremont Street built in 1941. In 1976, following Fesenko's Retirement (he died in 2003 at age 103) the congregation dissolved, proceeds went to fund his translation efforts on materials warmly welcomed in Ukraine following the end of USSR. Building now home of Chinese Baptist Congregation. |
| University | Jane and Finch | 1964 | Originally met at Gosford Blvd Public School, with building constructed in 1965. Congregation reportedly initially called "University Acres" for the neighbouring subdivision. |
| Victoria | The Junction | 1884-1969. | originally named West Toronto Junction; renamed Victoria to commemorate Queen's Jubilee. Merged with Royce Presbyterian to form Victoria-Royce Presbyterian. |
| Victoria-Royce | The Junction | 1969–2004 | Created as a merger of Victoria Presbyterian and Royce Presbyterian. Closed 2004, building today a condominium |
| Weston | Weston | 1847 | originally served by Scottish-trained Principals of Weston Collegiate. Building 1880; was known as the Old Church Weston when Westminister constructed in 1912; Minority fought to keep building open, then stayed in PCC in 1925, while Westminster joined United Church, and resumed under original name. |
| Westminster, East York | Old East York | 1921 | This congregation had its start as a mission from Riverdale Presbyterian in the spring of 1921. The earliest location was the back room of the Bank of Nova Scotia building at Pape and Gowan. The original frame church on what would become Floyd Ave, just west of Pape, opened in November, 1921. A larger stone church was completed immediately to the west of the original building in 1937. The congregation was known as Todmorden Presbyterian Church from its beginning until 1936. In 1993, Westminster Court, a 6-storey non-profit seniors' housing building was opened on the east side of the church property. |
| Westminster, Scarborough | Golden Mile | 1955 | originally (1910) a Sunday School sponsored by Isabella Walton (of St. Andrew's Scarborough). First building constructed in 1926, congregation formed in the 1950s, and second building constructed in 1959. Site re-developed in 1991 including apartments, Isabella Walton Daycare Centre and new Sanctuary. Stained glass window in Sanctuary of old Sunday School house detailed to show outhouse, used until 1959 building constructed with indoor plumbing. |
| Westview | O'Connor-Parkview | 1950 | Building constructed in two phases. |
| Wexford | Wexford | 1954 | Buildings constructed in 1957 and 1963. |
| Wychwood | Humewood-Cedarvale | 1925-1972. | Minority Group of former St. Columba's United (building now a Roman Catholic congregation at St. Clair and Vaughan). Merged with Davenport Presbyterian to form Wychwood-Davenport |
| Wychwood-Davenport | Humewood-Cedarvale | 1972 | Created as a merger of Wychwood Presbyterian and Davenport Presbyterian |
| Willowdale | Willowdale | 1925 | formed as Westminster Presbyterian, as a Mision of Knox Toronto, prior to Church Union. Full-fledged congregation from June 1925, part of charge 1925-35 with Thornhill and Richmond Hill. Renamed Willowdale in 1952 when building on Ellerslie Avenue constructed. |
| York Memorial | Silverthorn | 1934 | York congregation started almost a decade after nearby Silverthorn Mission went into United Church. Basement structure completed in 1937. In 1947, following World War II, renamed York Memorial as a war memorial. In 1959, neighbouring hsll opened, and named following death of long-time founding minister David P. Rowland. |