| Player | Position | Years with Stingrays | NHL draft selection | NHL team(s) (Years) |
|---|
| David Cooper | D | 1994–95 | Buffalo Sabres, round 1, #11 overall, 1992 | Toronto Maple Leafs (1996–98, 2000–01) |
| Steve McLaren | LW | 1994–95 | Chicago Blackhawks, round 4, #85 overall, 1994 | St. Louis Blues (2003–04) |
| Steve Shields | G | 1994–95 | Buffalo Sabres, round 5, #101 overall, 1991 | Buffalo Sabres (1995–98), San Jose Sharks (1998–01), Mighty Ducks of Anaheim (2001–02), Boston Bruins (2002–03), Florida Panthers (2003–04), Atlanta Thrashers (2005–06) |
| Sean Gauthier | G | 1995–96 | Winnipeg Jets, round 9, #181 overall, 1991 | San Jose Sharks (1998–99) |
| Martin Biron | G | 1997–98 | Buffalo Sabres, round 1, #16 overall, 1995 | Buffalo Sabres (1998–99, 2000–07), Philadelphia Flyers (2006–09), New York Islanders (2009–10), New York Rangers (2010–11) |
| Rich Peverley | C | 2004–05 | Not selected | Nashville Predators (2006–09), Atlanta Thrashers (2008–10), Boston Bruins (2010–2013), Dallas Stars (2013–present) |
| Jeremy Stevenson | LW | 2004–05 | Winnipeg Jets, round 3, #60 overall, 1992
Mighty Ducks of Anaheim, round 11, #262 overall, 1994 | Mighty Ducks of Anaheim (1995–98, 1999–00), Nashville Predators (2000–02, 2003–04, 2005–06), Minnesota Wild (2002–04), Dallas Stars (2005–06) |
| Garret Stroshein | F | 2004–05 | Not selected | Washington Capitals (2003–04) |
| Joey Tenute | C | 2004–05 | New Jersey Devils, round 8, #261 overall, 2003 | Washington Capitals (2005–06) |
| Deryk Engelland | D | 2005–06 | New Jersey Devils, round 6, #194 overall, 2000 | Pittsburgh Penguins (2009–present) |
| Jonas Johansson | RW | 2005–06 | Colorado Avalanche, round 1, #28 overall, 2002 | Washington Capitals (2005–06) |
| Jamie Fraser | D | 2005–07 | Not selected | New York Islanders (2008–09) |
| Micheal Haley | C | 2006–07 | Not selected | New York Islanders (2009–10) |
| Kyle Wilson | C | 2006–07 | Minnesota Wild, round 9, #272 overall, 2004 | Washington Capitals (2009–10), Columbus Blue Jackets (2010–11) |
| Travis Morin | C | 2006–09 | Washington Capitals, round 9, #263 overall, 2004 | Dallas Stars (2010–present) |
| Sean Collins | D | 2007–08 | Not selected | Washington Capitals (2008–09) |
| Andrew Gordon | RW | 2007–08 | Washington Capitals, round 7, #197 overall, 2004 | Washington Capitals (2008–10) |
| Steve Pinizzotto | RW | 2007–09 | Not selected | Vancouver Canucks (2012–13) |
| Jeremy Duchesne | G | 2008–09 | Philadelphia Flyers, round 4, #119 overall, 2005 | Philadelphia Flyers (2009–10) |
| Michal Neuvirth | G | 2008–09 | Washington Capitals, round 2, #34 overall, 2006 | Washington Capitals (2008–14), Buffalo Sabres (2014–15), New York Islanders (2015), Philadelphia Flyers (2015–present) |
| Stefan Della Rovere | LW | 2008–09 | Washington Capitals, round 7, #204 overall, 2008 | St. Louis Blues (2010–11) |
| James Reimer | G | 2008–09 | Toronto Maple Leafs, round 4, #99 overall, 2006 | Toronto Maple Leafs (2010–15), San Jose Sharks (2015–16), Florida Panthers (2016–present) |
| Braden Holtby | G | 2009–10 | Washington Capitals, round 4, #93 overall, 2008 | Washington Capitals (2010–present) |
| Joe Finley | D | 2009–11 | Washington Capitals, round 1, #27 overall, 2005 | New York Islanders (2012–13) |
| Philipp Grubauer | G | 2011–12 | Washington Capitals, round 4, #112 overall, 2010 | Washington Capitals (2012–2018) Colorado Avalanche (2018–present) |