| # Overall | Team | Player | College | | {{Center|Round 1}} | 1 | Rochester
(from Bridgeport) | Josh Coffman | Syracuse |
| 2 | Boston | Steve Dusseau | Georgetown |
| 3 | Boston (from NJ) | Conor Gill | Virginia |
| 4 | Bridgeport
(from Rochester) | Nick Polanco | Hofstra |
| 5 | Rochester
(from Boston) | John Glatzel | Syracuse |
| 6 | Baltimore
(from Long Island) | Tom Kessler | Hofstra |
| {{Center|Round 2}} | 7 | Long Island
(from Bridgeport) | Matt McFarland | Massachusetts |
| 8 | Boston | Don Little | Massachusetts |
| 9 | New Jersey | Scott Dooley | Hofstra |
| 10 | Rochester | Will Driscoll | Penn State |
| 11 | Long Island | Dan Paccione | Massachusetts |
| 12 | Baltimore | Justin Cynar | Cornell |
| {{Center|Round 3}} | 13 | Boston
(from Bridgeport) | Jimmy Mormile | Brown |
| 14 | Boston | Marko Lujic | Yale |
| 15 | New Jersey | Brian Solliday | Syracuse |
| 16 | Boston
(from Rochester) | Galen Beers | Cornell |
| 17 | Long Island | Nick Murtha | Johns Hopkins |
| 18 | Baltimore | Billy St. George | Syracuse |
|
| {{Center|Round 4}} | 19 | Bridgeport | Devin Ryan | Notre Dame |
| 20 | Long Island
(from Boston) | Tim Pearson | Army |
| 21 | Bridgeport
(from New Jersey) | Josh Tankersley | Towson |
| 22 | Rochester | Mark Koontz | Virginia |
| 23 | Rochester
(from Bridgeport) | Nate Watkins | Maryland |
| 24 | Baltimore | Brad Reppert | Towson |
| {{Center|Round 5}} | 25 | Bridgeport | Marc Morley | Massachusetts |
| 26 | Boston | Scott Yavarow | Bentley |
| 27 | New Jersey | P.J. DiConza | Johns Hopkins |
| 28 | Rochester | Dan Chemotti | Duke |
| 29 | Bridgeport
(from Long Island) | Nick Russo | Virginia |
| 30 | Baltimore | Brenndan Mohler | Virginia |
|