| Rank | Player | Teams played for | Position | Ref |
|---|
| 1 | Eddie Brown | Albany/Indiana Firebirds | Offensive Specialist | [1] |
| 2 | Barry Wagner | Orlando Predators
San Jose SaberCats | Wide receiver/Defensive back | [2] |
| 3 | George LaFrance | Detroit Drive
Tampa Bay Storm
New Jersey Red Dogs | Offensive Specialist | [2] |
| 4 | Jay Gruden | Tampa Bay Storm
Orlando Predators | Quarterback | [2] |
| 5 | Hunkie Cooper | Arizona Rattlers | Wide Receiver/Linebacker | [2] |
| 6 | James Baron | Nashville Kats
Chicago Rush | Offensive Lineman/Defensive Lineman | [2] |
| 7 | Sylvester Bembery | New England Steamrollers
Albany Firebirds
Tampa Bay Storm
Buffalo Destroyers | Offensive Lineman/Defensive Lineman | [2] |
| 8 | Sherdrick Bonner | Arizona Rattlers | Quarterback | [2] |
| 9 | Stevie Thomas | Tampa Bay Storm
Orlando Predators | Wide receiver/Linebacker | [2] |
| 10 | Dwayne Dixon | Washington Commandos
Detroit Drive | Wide receiver/Linebacker | [2] |
| 11 | Aaron Garcia | Arizona Rattlers
Connecticut Coyotes
New Jersey Red Dogs
Iowa Barnstormers
New York Dragons | Quarterback | [2] |
| 12 | Kurt Warner | Iowa Barnstormers | Quarterback | [2] |
| 13 | Sam Hernandez | Las Vegas Sting
Anaheim Piranhas
San Jose SaberCats | Offensive Lineman/Defensive Lineman | [2] |
| 14 | Cory Fleming | Nashville Kats
Carolina Cobras
Orlando Predators | Wide receiver/Linebacker | [2] |
| 14 | Greg Hopkins | Albany/Indiana Firebirds
Los Angeles Avengers | Wide receiver/Linebacker | [2] |
| 16 | Alvin Rettig | Detroit Drive | Fullback/Linebacker | [2] |
| 17 | Randy Gatewood | Arizona Rattlers | Wide receiver/Defensive back | [2] |
| 17 | Gary Mullen | Denver Dynamite
Los Angeles Cobras
Detroit Drive
Cincinnati Rockers
Milwaukee Mustangs | Wide receiver/Defensive back | [2] |
| 19 | John Corker | Detroit Drive
Miami Hooters | Offensive Lineman/Defensive Lineman | [2] |
| 20 | Bob McMillen | Arizona Rattlers
Chicago Rush | Fullback/Linebacker | [2] |
1. ^{{cite web |url=http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2297305 |title='Touchdown' Eddie Brown tops Arena top 20 list |date=January 18, 2006 |publisher=ESPN Internet Ventures |work=www.espn.go.com |accessdate=June 3, 2013}}
2. ^1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 {{cite news |url=http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2006-01-19/sports/ARENACHART19_1_bay-storm-orlando-predators-barry-wagner |title=AFL announces all-time greats |date=January 19, 2006 |author=Tania Ganguli |newspaper=Orlando Sentinel |accessdate=June 3, 2013}}
{{AFL Awards}}