“Religious experience”的意思、由来-开放百科全书

A religious experience (sometimes known as a spiritual experience, sacred experience, or mystical experience) is a subjective experience which is interpreted within a religious framework.{{sfn|Samy|1998|p=80}} The concept originated in the 19th century, as a defense against the growing rationalism of Western society.{{sfn|Sharf|2000}} William James popularised the concept.{{sfn|Sharf|2000}}

Many religious and mystical traditions see religious experiences (particularly that knowledge which comes with them) as revelations caused by divine agency rather than ordinary natural processes. They are considered real encounters with God or gods, or real contact with higher-order realities of which humans are not ordinarily aware.^[1]

Skeptics may hold that religious experience is an evolved feature of the human brain amenable to normal scientific study.{{refn|group=note|Such study may be said to have begun with the American psychologist and philosopher William James in his 1901/02 Gifford Lectures later published as The Varieties of Religious Experience.}} The commonalities and differences between religious experiences across different cultures have enabled scholars to categorize them for academic study.^[2]

Definitions

William James

Psychologist and philosopher William James described four characteristics of mystical experience in The Varieties of Religious Experience. According to James, such an experience is:

Norman Habel

Norman Habel defines religious experiences as the structured way in which a believer enters into a relationship with, or gains an awareness of, the sacred within the context of a particular religious tradition (Habel, O'Donoghue and Maddox: 1993). Religious experiences are by their very nature preternatural; that is, out of the ordinary or beyond the natural order of things. They may be difficult to distinguish observationally from psychopathological states such as psychoses or other forms of altered awareness (Charlesworth: 1988). Not all preternatural experiences are considered to be religious experiences. Following Habel's definition, psychopathological states or drug-induced states of awareness are not considered to be religious experiences because they are mostly not performed within the context of a particular religious tradition.

Moore and Habel identify two classes of religious experiences: the immediate and the mediated religious experience (Moore and Habel: 1982).

Richard Swinburne

In his book Faith and Reason, the philosopher Richard Swinburne formulated five categories into which all religious experiences fall:

Swinburne also suggested two principles for the assessment of religious experiences:

Rudolf Otto

The German thinker Rudolf Otto (1869–1937) argues that there is one common factor to all religious experience, independent of the cultural background. In his book The Idea of the Holy (1923) he identifies this factor as the numinous. The "numinous" experience has two aspects:

The numinous experience also has a personal quality to it, in that the person feels to be in communion with a holy other. Otto sees the numinous as the only possible religious experience. He states: "There is no religion in which it [the numinous] does not live as the real innermost core and without it no religion would be worthy of the name" (Otto: 1972). Otto does not take any other kind of religious experience such as ecstasy and enthusiasm seriously and is of the opinion that they belong to the 'vestibule of religion'.

Related terms

History

Origins

The notion of "religious experience" can be traced back to William James, who used the term "religious experience" in his book, The Varieties of Religious Experience.{{sfn|Hori|1999|p=47}} It is considered to be the classic work in the field, and references to James' ideas are common at professional conferences. James distinguished between institutional religion and personal religion. Institutional religion refers to the religious group or organization, and plays an important part in a society's culture. Personal religion, in which the individual has mystical experience, can be experienced regardless of the culture.

The origins of the use of this term can be dated further back.{{sfn|Sharf|2000}} In the 18th, 19th, and 20th centuries, several historical figures put forth very influential views that religion and its beliefs can be grounded in experience itself. While Kant held that moral experience justified religious beliefs, John Wesley in addition to stressing individual moral exertion thought that the religious experiences in the Methodist movement (paralleling the Romantic Movement) were foundational to religious commitment as a way of life.^[3]

Wayne Proudfoot traces the roots of the notion of "religious experience" to the German theologian Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768–1834), who argued that religion is based on a feeling of the infinite. The notion of "religious experience" was used by Schleiermacher and Albert Ritschl to defend religion against the growing scientific and secular critique, and defend the view that human (moral and religious) experience justifies religious beliefs.{{sfn|Sharf|2000}}

The notion of "religious experience" was adopted by many scholars of religion, of which William James was the most influential.{{sfn|Sharf|2000|p=271}}{{refn|group=note|James also gives descriptions of conversion experiences. The Christian model of dramatic conversions, based on the role-model of Paul's conversion, may also have served as a model for Western interpretations and expectations regarding "enlightenment", similar to Protestant influences on Theravada Buddhism, as described by Carrithers: "It rests upon the notion of the primacy of religious experiences, preferably spectacular ones, as the origin and legitimation of religious action. But this presupposition has a natural home, not in Buddhism, but in Christian and especially Protestant Christian movements which prescribe a radical conversion."{{sfn|Carrithers|1983|p=18}} See Sekida for an example of this influence of William James and Christian conversion stories, mentioning Luther{{sfn|Sekida|1985|p=196-197}} and St. Paul.{{sfn|Sekida|1985|p=251}} See also McMahan for the influence of Christian thought on Buddhism.{{sfn|McMahan|2008}}}}

A broad range of western and eastern movements have incorporated and influenced the emergence of the modern notion of "mystical experience", such as the Perennial philosophy, Transcendentalism, Universalism, the Theosophical Society, New Thought, Neo-Vedanta and Buddhist modernism.{{sfn|McMahan|2008}}{{sfn|King|2001}}

Perennial philosophy

According to the Perennial philosophy, the mystical experiences in all religions are essentially the same. It supposes that many, if not all of the world's great religions, have arisen around the teachings of mystics, including Buddha, Jesus, Lao Tze, and Krishna. It also sees most religious traditions describing fundamental mystical experience, at least esoterically. A major proponent in the 20th century was Aldous Huxley, who "was heavily influenced in his description by Vivekananda's neo-Vedanta and the idiosyncratic version of Zen exported to the west by D.T. Suzuki. Both of these thinkers expounded their versions of the perennialist thesis",{{sfn|King|2002|p=163}} which they originally received from western thinkers and theologians.{{sfn|King|2002}}

Transcendentalism and Unitarian Universalism

New Thought

New Thought promotes the ideas that Infinite Intelligence, or God, is everywhere, spirit is the totality of real things, true human selfhood is divine, divine thought is a force for good, sickness originates in the mind, and "right thinking" has a healing effect.^[7]^[8] New Thought was propelled along by a number of spiritual thinkers and philosophers and emerged through a variety of religious denominations and churches, particularly the Unity Church, Religious Science, and Church of Divine Science.{{sfn|Lewis|Melton|1992|p=16–18}} The Home of Truth, which belongs to the New Thought movement has, from its inception as the Pacific Coast Metaphysical Bureau in the 1880s, disseminated the teachings of the Hindu teacher Swami Vivekananda.^[9]

Theosophical Society

The Theosophical Society was formed in 1875 by Helena Blavatsky, Henry Steel Olcott, William Quan Judge and others to advance the spiritual principles and search for Truth known as Theosophy.^[10]{{refn|group=note|

The Theosophical Society searched for 'secret teachings' in Asian religions. It has been influential on modernist streams in several Asian religions, notably Hindu reform movements, the revival of Theravada Buddhism, and D.T. Suzuki, who popularized the idea of enlightenment as insight into a timeless, transcendent reality.^[11]^[12]{{sfn|McMahan|2008}} Another example can be seen in Paul Brunton's A Search in Secret India, which introduced Ramana Maharshi to a western audience.

Orientalism and the "pizza effect"

The interplay between western and eastern notions of religion is an important factor in the development of modern mysticism. In the 19th century, when Asian countries were colonialised by western states, a process of cultural mimesis began.{{sfn|King|2002}}{{sfn|McMahan|2010}}{{sfn|Sharf|2000}} In this process, Western ideas about religion, especially the notion of "religious experience" were introduced to Asian countries by missionaries, scholars and the Theosophical Society, and amalgamated in a new understanding of the Indian and Buddhist traditions. This amalgam was exported back to the West as 'authentic Asian traditions', and acquired a great popularity in the west. Due to this western popularity, it also gained authority back in India, Sri Lanka and Japan.{{sfn|King|2002}}{{sfn|McMahan|2010}}{{sfn|Sharf|2000}}

The best-known representatives of this amalgamated tradition are Annie Besant (Theosophical Society), Swami Vivekenanda and Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan (Neo-Vedanta), Anagarika Dharmapala, a 19th-century Sri Lankan Buddhist activist who founded the Maha Bodhi Society, and D.T. Suzuki, a Japanese scholar and Zen-Buddhist. A synonymous term for this broad understanding is nondualism. This mutual influence is also known as the pizza effect.

Criticism

The notion of "experience" has been criticised.{{sfn|Sharf|1995a}}{{sfn|Mohr|2000|p=282-286}}{{sfn|Low|2006|p=12}}

"Religious empiricism" is seen as highly problematic and was – during the period in-between world wars – famously rejected by Karl Barth.^[13] In the 20th century, religious as well as moral experience as justification for religious beliefs still holds sway. Some influential modern scholars holding this liberal theological view are Charles Raven and the Oxford physicist/theologian Charles Coulson.^[14]

Robert Sharf points out that "experience" is a typical Western term, which has found its way into Asian religiosity via western influences.{{sfn|Sharf|1995a}}{{refn|group=note|Robert Sharf: "[T]he role of experience in the history of Buddhism has been greatly exaggerated in contemporary scholarship. Both historical and ethnographic evidence suggests that the privileging of experience may well be traced to certain twentieth-century reform movements, notably those that urge a return to zazen or vipassana meditation, and these reforms were profoundly influenced by religious developments in the west [...] While some adepts may indeed experience "altered states" in the course of their training, critical analysis shows that such states do not constitute the reference point for the elaborate Buddhist discourse pertaining to the "path".{{sfn|Sharf|1995b|p=1}}}} The notion of "experience" introduces a false notion of duality between "experiencer" and "experienced", whereas the essence of kensho is the realisation of the "non-duality" of observer and observed.{{sfn|Hori|1994|p=30}}{{sfn|Samy|1998|p=82}} "Pure experience" does not exist; all experience is mediated by intellectual and cognitive activity.{{sfn|Mohr|2000|p=282}}{{sfn|Samy|1998|p=80-82}} The specific teachings and practices of a specific tradition may even determine what "experience" someone has, which means that this "experience" is not the proof of the teaching, but a result of the teaching.{{sfn|Samy|1998|p=80}} A pure consciousness without concepts, reached by "cleansing the doors of perception",{{refn|group=note|William Blake: "If the doors of perception were cleansed every thing would appear to man as it is, infinite. For man has closed himself up, till he sees all things thru' narrow chinks of his cavern."^[15]}} would be an overwhelming chaos of sensory input without coherence.{{sfn|Mohr|2000|p=284}}

Causes of religious experiences

Religious practices: traditions offer a wide variety of religious practices to induce religious experiences:

Drugs: religious experiences may also be caused by the use of entheogens, such as:

Neurophysiological origins: Religious experiences may have neurophysiological origins. These are studied in the field of neurotheology, and the cognitive science of religion, and include near-death experience^[28] and the "Koren helmet"^[29] Causes may be:

Religious practices

Western

Neoplatonism

Neoplatonism is the modern term for a school of religious and mystical philosophy that took shape in the 3rd century AD, founded by Plotinus and based on the teachings of Plato and earlier Platonists.

Neoplatonism teaches that along the same road by which it descended the soul must retrace its steps back to the supreme Good. It must first of all return to itself. This is accomplished by the practice of virtue, which aims at likeness to God, and leads up to God. By means of ascetic observances the human becomes once more a spiritual and enduring being, free from all sin. But there is still a higher attainment; it is not enough to be sinless, one must become "God", (henosis). This is reached through contemplation of the primeval Being, the One – in other words, through an ecstatic approach to it.

It is only in a state of perfect passivity and repose that the soul can recognize and touch the primeval Being. Hence the soul must first pass through a spiritual curriculum. Beginning with the contemplation of corporeal things in their multiplicity and harmony, it then retires upon itself and withdraws into the depths of its own being, rising thence to the nous, the world of ideas. But even there it does not find the Highest, the One; it still hears a voice saying, "not we have made ourselves." The last stage is reached when, in the highest tension and concentration, beholding in silence and utter forgetfulness of all things, it is able as it were to lose itself. Then it may see God, the foundation of life, the source of being, the origin of all good, the root of the soul. In that moment it enjoys the highest indescribable bliss; it is as it were swallowed up of divinity, bathed in the light of eternity. Porphyry tells us that on four occasions during the six years of their intercourse Plotinus attained to this ecstatic union with God.

Alcoholics Anonymous Twelfth Step

The twelfth step of the Alcoholics Anonymous program states that "Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics and to practice these principles in all our affairs".^[33] The terms “spiritual experience” and “spiritual awaken-ing” are used many times in "The Big Book of Alcoholics Anonymous"^[34] which argues that a spiritual experience is needed to bring about recovery from alcoholism.^[35]

Christianity

Christian mysticism

Christian doctrine generally maintains that God dwells in all Christians and that they can experience God directly through belief in Jesus,^[36] Christian mysticism aspires to apprehend spiritual truths inaccessible through intellectual means, typically by emulation of Christ. William Inge divides this scala perfectionis into three stages: the "purgative" or ascetic stage, the "illuminative" or contemplative stage, and the third, "unitive" stage, in which God may be beheld "face to face."^[37]

The third stage, usually called contemplation in the Western tradition, refers to the experience of oneself as united with God in some way. The experience of union varies, but it is first and foremost always associated with a reuniting with Divine love. The underlying theme here is that God, the perfect goodness,^[38] is known or experienced at least as much by the heart as by the intellect since, in the words of 1 John 4:16: "God is love, and he who abides in love abides in God and God in him." Some approaches to classical mysticism would consider the first two phases as preparatory to the third, explicitly mystical experience; but others state that these three phases overlap and intertwine.

Hesychasm

Based on Christ's injunction in the Gospel of Matthew to "go into your closet to pray",^[39] hesychasm in tradition has been the process of retiring inward by ceasing to register the senses, in order to achieve an experiential knowledge of God (see theoria).

The highest goal of the hesychast is the experiential knowledge of God. In the 14th Century, the possibility of this experiential knowledge of God was challenged by a Calabrian monk, Barlaam, who, although he was formally a member of the Orthodox Church, had been trained in Western Scholastic theology. Barlaam asserted that our knowledge of God can only be propositional. The practice of the hesychasts was defended by St. Gregory Palamas.

Islam

While all Muslims believe that they are on the pathway to God and will become close to God in Paradise – after death and after the "Final Judgment" – Sufis believe that it is possible to become close to God and to experience this closeness while one is alive.^[40]

Sufis believe in a tripartite way to God as explained by a tradition attributed to the Prophet,"The Shariah are my words (aqwal), the tariqa are my actions (amal), and the haqiqa is my interior states (ahwal)". Shariah, tariqa and haqiqa are mutually interdependent.

The tariqa, the ‘path’ on which the mystics walk, has been defined as ‘the path which comes out of the Shariah, for the main road is called shar, the path, tariq.’ No mystical experience can be realized if the binding injunctions of the Shariah are not followed faithfully first. The path, tariqa, however, is narrower and more difficult to walk. It leads the adept, called salik (wayfarer), in his suluk (wandering), through different stations (maqam) until he reaches his goal, the perfect tauhid, the existential confession that God is One.^[41]

Asia

Buddhism

In Theravada Buddhism practice is described in the threefold training of discipline (śīla), meditative concentration (samādhi), and transcendent wisdom (prajñā). Zen-Buddhism emphaises the sole practice of meditation, while Vajrayana Buddhism utilizes a wide variety of practices. While the main aim of meditation and prajna is to let go of attachments, it may also result in a comprehension of the Buddha-nature and the inherent lucidness of the mind.

Different varieties of religious experience are described in detail in the Śūraṅgama Sūtra. In its section on the fifty skandha-maras, each of the five skandhas has ten skandha-maras associated with it, and each skandha-mara is described in detail as a deviation from correct samādhi. These skandha-maras are also known as the "fifty skandha demons" in some English-language publications.^[42]

It is also believed that supernormal abilities are developed from meditation, which are termed "higher knowledge" (abhijñā), or "spiritual power" (ṛddhi). One early description found in the Samyutta Nikaya, which mentions abilities such as:^[43]

Hinduism

Building on European philosophers, Radhakrishnan reduced religion "to the core experience of reality in its fundamental unity".

Meher Baba

According to the syncretistic Indian spiritual teacher Meher Baba, "Spiritual experience involves more than can be grasped by mere intellect. This is often emphasised by calling it a mystical experience. Mysticism is often regarded as something anti-intellectual, obscure and confused, or impractical and unconnected with experience. In fact, true mysticism is none of these. There is nothing irrational in true mysticism when it is, as it should be, a vision of Reality. It is a form of perception which is absolutely unclouded, and so practical that it can be lived every moment of life and expressed in every-day duties. Its connection with experience is so deep that, in one sense, it is the final understanding of all experience."^[48]

Psychedelic drugs

Dr. R.R. Griffiths and colleagues at Johns Hopkins University had done a double blind study evaluating the psychological effects of psilocybin comparing with methylphenidate(Ritalin). 36 hallucinogen-naive adults were recruited. 22 of the 36 reported mystical experience. The effect persisted even at 2 and 14 months follow-up.^[49]^[50] The group continued to do studies in evaluating the effect with different dosing^[51] and the resulting mystical effect on personality.^[52]

Neurophysiology

Psychiatry

A 2012 paper suggested that psychiatric conditions associated with psychotic spectrum symptoms may be possible explanations for revelatory driven experiences and activities such as those of Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Saint Paul.^[53]

Neuroscience

Neuroscience of religion

Neuroscience of religion, also known as neurotheology, biotheology or spiritual neuroscience,^[54] is the study of correlations of neural phenomena with subjective experiences of spirituality and hypotheses to explain these phenomena. Proponents of neurotheology claim that there is a neurological and evolutionary basis for subjective experiences traditionally categorized as spiritual or religious.^[55]

The neuroscience of religion takes neural correlates as the basis of cognitive functions and religious experiences. These religious experience are thereby emergent properties of neural correlates. This approach does not necessitate exclusion of the Self, but interprets the Self as influenced or otherwise acted upon by underlying neural mechanisms. Proponents argue that religious experience can be evoked through stimulus of specific brain regions and/or can be observed through measuring increase in activity of specific brain regions.^[56]{{refn|group=note|This is contrary to the view of William James and F.D.E. Schleirmacher who viewed religious experience as a "preconceptual, immediate affective event."^[57]^[58]}}

An alternate approach is influenced by personalism, and exists contra-parallel to the reductionist approach. It focuses on the Self as the object of interest,{{refn|group=note|According to the Standford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, "[personalism] emphasizes the significance, uniqueness and inviolability of the person, as well as the person's essentially relational or communitarian dimension."^[59]}} the same object of interest as in religion.{{citation needed|date=October 2017}} According to Patrick McNamara, a proponent of personalism, the Self is a neural entity that controls rather than consists of the cognitive functions being processed in brain regions.^[60]^[61]{{refn|group=note|It is important{{why?|date=October 2017}} to note that this school of thought evolved out of the thinking of St. Thomas Aquinas due to his focus on the individual uniqueness of the person and his subsequent discourse on the supposed nature of the Trinity and Jesus' divine/human existence.{{citation needed|date=October 2017}} However, personalism and irreligiosity are not mutually exclusive as atheist personalism also functions within the greater school of thought.{{citation needed|date=October 2017}}}}

Neurological evolutionary basis

A biological basis for religious experience may exist.^[62]^[61] References to the supernatural or mythical beings first appeared approximately 40,000 years ago.^[63]^[69] A popular theory posits that dopaminergic brain systems are the evolutionary basis for human intellect^[64]^[69] and more specifically abstract reasoning.^[69] The capacity for religious thought arises from the capability to employ abstract reasoning. There is no evidence to support the theory that abstract reasoning, generally or with regard to religious thought, evolved independent of the dopaminergic axis.^[69]

Religious behavior has been linked to "extrapersonal brain systems that predominate the ventromedial cortex and rely heavily on dopaminergic transmission."^[65] A biphasic effect exists with regard to activation of the dopaminergic axis and/or ventromedial cortex. While mild activation can evoke a perceived understanding of the supernatural, extreme activation can lead to delusions characteristic of psychosis.^[69] Stress can cause the depletion of 5-hydroxytryptamine, also referred to as serotonin.^[66] The ventromedial 5-HT axis is involved in peripersonal activities such as emotional arousal, social skills, and visual feedback.^[69] When 5-HT is decreased or depleted, one may become subject to "incorrect attributions of self-initiated or internally generated activity (e.g. hallucinations)."^[67]

Studies of the brain

Early studies in the 1950s and 1960s attempted to use EEGs to study brain wave patterns correlated with spiritual states. During the 1980s Dr. Michael Persinger stimulated the temporal lobes of human subjects^[68] with a weak magnetic field. His subjects claimed to have a sensation of "an ethereal presence in the room."^[69] Some current studies use neuroimaging to localize brain regions active, or differentially active, during religious experiences.^[70]^[71]^[72] These neuroimaging studies have implicated a number of brain regions, including the limbic system, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, superior parietal lobe, and caudate nucleus.^[73]^[74]^[75] Based on the complex nature of religious experience, it is likely that they are mediated by an interaction of neural mechanisms that all add a small piece to the overall experience.^[74]

According to the neurotheologist Andrew B. Newberg, neurological processes which are driven by the repetitive, rhythmic stimulation which is typical of human ritual, and which contribute to the delivery of transcendental feelings of connection to a universal unity.{{clarify|incomplete sentence|date=June 2012}} They posit, however, that physical stimulation alone is not sufficient to generate transcendental unitive experiences. For this to occur they say there must be a blending of the rhythmic stimulation with ideas. Once this occurs "...ritual turns a meaningful idea into a visceral experience."^[76] Moreover, they say that humans are compelled to act out myths by the biological operations of the brain due to what they call the "inbuilt tendency of the brain to turn thoughts into actions."

Temporal lobe epilepsy

Integrating religious experience

Several psychologists have proposed models in which religious experiences are part of a process of transformation of the self.

The notion of the numinous was an important concept in the writings of Carl Jung. Jung regarded numinous experiences as fundamental to an understanding of the individuation process because of their association with experiences of synchronicity in which the presence of archetypes is felt.^[88]^[89]

McNamara proposes that religious experiences may help in "decentering" the self, and transform it into an integral self which is closer to an ideal self.{{sfn|McNamara|2014}}

Transpersonal psychology is a school of psychology that studies the transpersonal, self-transcendent or spiritual aspects of the human experience. The Journal of Transpersonal Psychology describes transpersonal psychology as "the study of humanity’s highest potential, and with the recognition, understanding, and realization of unitive, spiritual, and transcendent states of consciousness" (Lajoie and Shapiro, 1992:91). Issues considered in transpersonal psychology include spiritual self-development, peak experiences, mystical experiences, systemic trance and other metaphysical experiences of living.

See also

Notes

1. ^The Argument from Religious Experience http://www.philosophyofreligion.info/?page_id=41
2. ^{{cite book |last=Batson, C. D., Schoenrade, P., & Ventis, W. L.|title=Religion and the individual: A social psychological perspective.|year=1993 |publisher=Oxford University Press}}
3. ^Issues in Science and Religion, Ian Barbour, Prentice-Hall, 1966, page 68, 79
4. ^{{cite web|url=http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/transcendentalism/ |title=Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Transcendentalism |publisher=Plato.stanford.edu |accessdate=2013-11-06}}
5. ^¹²³{{cite web|author=Jone Johnson Lewis |url=http://www.transcendentalists.com/what.htm |title=Jone John Lewis, What is Transcendentalism? |publisher=Transcendentalists.com |accessdate=2013-11-06}}
6. ^{{cite web |url=http://archive.uua.org/re/other/andrews.html |title=Barry Andrews, The Roots Of Unitarian Universalist Spirituality In New England Transcendentalism |publisher=Archive.uua.org |date=1999-03-12 |accessdate=2013-11-06 |deadurl=yes |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20130921054734/http://archive.uua.org/re/other/andrews.html |archivedate=2013-09-21 |df= }}
7. ^Declaration of Principles (accessed 2008–09)
8. ^New Thought info, Statement of beliefs (accessed 2008–09)
9. ^{{cite web|url=http://thehomeoftruth.org/id4.html |title=tHe HOme of Truth, Our History |publisher=Thehomeoftruth.org |accessdate=2013-11-06}}
10. ^¹Melton, Gordon J. (Sr. ed.) (1990). "Theosophical Society". New Age Encyclopedia. Farmington Hills, Michigan: Gale Research. pp. 458–461. {{ISBN|0-8103-7159-6}}
11. ^{{cite web|url=http://www.thezensite.com/ZenEssays/CriticalZen/whose%20zen_sharf.pdf |first=Robert H. |last=Sharf |title=Whose Zen? Zen Nationalism Revisited |accessdate=2013-11-06}}
12. ^{{cite web|url=http://www.thezensite.com/ZenEssays/HistoricalZen/Chan_in_China.html |title=Hu Shih: Ch'an (Zen) Buddhism in China. Its History and Method |publisher=Thezensite.com |accessdate=2013-11-06}}
13. ^Issues in Science and Religion, Ian Barbour, Prentice-Hall, 1966, page 114, 116-119
14. ^Issues in Science and Religion, Ian Barbour, Prentice-Hall, 1966, p. 126-127
15. ^Quote DB
16. ^{{cite web |title=Exploring the biology of religious experience |url=http://www.natcath.com/NCR_Online/archives/042001/042001a.htm |website=NRC online}}
17. ^{{Cite journal |title=The Emotional Effects of Music on Religious Experience: A Study of the Pentecostal-Charismatic Style of Music and Worship |url=http://pom.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/30/1/8 |journal=Psychology of Music|volume=30 |pages=8–27 |doi=10.1177/0305735602301004 |year=2002 |last1=Miller |first1=Mandi M. |last2=Strongman |first2=Kenneth T. }}
18. ^{{cite web |title=ufis seek ultimate religious experience through mystic trances or altered states of consciousness, often induced through twirling dances |url=http://www.experiencefestival.com/a/Sufism/id/87217 |website=Sufism: New Age Spirituality Dictionary}}
19. ^{{cite web |title=Self-inflicted Pain in Religious Experience |url=http://faithfaq.com/pain.htm |website=www.faithfaq.com |access-date=July 11, 2006}}
20. ^{{cite web |title=Divining the brain |url=http://www.salon.com/books/int/2006/09/20/newberg/ |website=Salon.com |access-date=September 20, 2006}}
21. ^Daniélou, Alain: Yoga, methods of re-integration
22. ^{{cite journal |last=Watts |first=Alan |title=Psychedelics and Religious Experience |journal=California Law Review |volume=56 |pages=74–85 |number=1 |date=January 1968 |doi=10.2307/3479497|jstor=3479497 }}
23. ^{{cite web |title=The Salvia divinorum FAQ |date=July 30, 2012 |quote=Those who think of the salvia experience in religious, spiritual, or mystical terms may speak of such things as enlightenment, satori, and "cleansing the doors of perception." |url=http://www.sagewisdom.org/faq.html |website=SageWisdom.org |access-date=August 26, 2007}}
24. ^{{cite web |title=A Note on the Safety of Peyote when Used Religiously. |url=http://www.csp.org/practices/entheogens/docs/baggot-peyote.html |website=www.csp.org Council on Spiritual Practices |access-date=July 11, 2006}}
25. ^{{cite news |title=Drug's Mystical Properties Confirmed |url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/07/10/AR2006071001304.html |work=Washington Post |access-date=July 11, 2006}}
26. ^{{cite web |title=The Psychology of Religion: An Empirical Approach |url=http://www.csp.org/chrestomathy/psychology_of-spilka.html |website=Council on Spiritual Practices |access-date=July 11, 2006}}
27. ^{{cite web |last1=Adamson |first1=Sophia |last2=Metzner |first2=Ralph |title=The Nature of the MDMA Experience and Its Role in Healing, Psychotherapy, and Spiritual Practice |url=http://www.maps.org/research-archive/mdma/revision.html |website=maps.org |publisher=MAPS |accessdate=16 December 2018}}
28. ^Moody, Raymond. Life After Life {{ISBN|0-06-251739-2}}
29. ^{{cite journal |last1 = Persinger |first1 = MA|year = 2010 |title = The Electromagnetic Induction of Mystical and Altered States Within the Laboratory |journal = Journal of Consciousness Exploration & Research |pages = 808–830 |issue = 7 |volume = 1 |issn= 2153-8212|display-authors=etal}}
30. ^{{cite news |title=God on the Brain |work=BBC |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/2865009.stm |access-date=March 20, 2003}}
31. ^{{cite web |last=Taylor |first=Jill Bolte |title=My Stroke of Insight |website=TED |url=http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/jill_bolte_taylor_s_powerful_stroke_of_insight.html |access-date= July 2, 2008}}
32. ^Katie, Byron. Loving What Is page xi {{ISBN|1-4000-4537-1}}
33. ^http://www.aa.org.au/members/twelve-steps.php
34. ^{{cite web | url=http://www.aa.org/pages/en_US/alcoholics-anonymous | title=Alcoholics Anonymous : Alcoholics Anonymous}}
35. ^http://www.aa.org/assets/en_US/en_bigbook_appendiceii.pdf
36. ^John 7:16–39
37. ^Christian Mysticism (1899 Bampton Lectures)
38. ^Theologia Germanica, public domain
39. ^{{bibleref|Matthew|6:5–6|KJV}}
40. ^Sufism, Sufis, and Sufi Orders: Sufism's Many Paths
41. ^Annemarie Schimmel, Mystical Dimensions of Islam (1975) pg.99
42. ^{{cite web|url=http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/Buddhism/Shurangama/ss8foreword.html|title=Fifty Skandha Demon States: Forward|author=Ron Epstein}}
43. ^Bhikkhu Bodhi. The Connected Discourses of the Buddha. 2000. p. 1727
44. ^{{cite book|title=Contemporary Hinduism: Ritual, Culture, and Practice|first=Robin |last=Rinehart|page=195|publisher=ABC-CLIO}}
45. ^Bhagavad Gita, Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan
46. ^{{cite book|title=Reincarnation in America: An Esoteric History|page=218|first=Lee|last=Irwin|year=2017|publisher=Lexington Books|quote=Neo-Vedanta teachings as an expression of a radical nondualism, an inherent unity within all religions and within all persons}}
47. ^{{cite book|title=Bringing the Sacred Down to Earth: Adventures in Comparative Religion|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=A0pPY6p9cpQC&pg=PA115|first=Corinne|last=Dempsey|publisher=Oxford University Press|year=2011|isbn=9780199860326}}
48. ^Baba, Meher: Discourses, Sufism Reoriented, 1967, p. 20
49. ^{{ cite journal | pmid= 16826400 | doi=10.1007/s00213-006-0457-5 | volume=187 | issue=3 | title=Psilocybin can occasion mystical-type experiences having substantial and sustained personal meaning and spiritual significance | date=August 2006 | journal=Psychopharmacology | pages=268–83; discussion 284–92 | last1 = Griffiths | first1 = RR | last2 = Richards | first2 = WA | last3 = McCann | first3 = U | last4 = Jesse | first4 = R}}
50. ^{{cite journal | pmid=18593735 | doi=10.1177/0269881108094300 | volume=22 |issue = 6| title=Mystical-type experiences occasioned by psilocybin mediate the attribution of personal meaning and spiritual significance 14 months later | date=August 2008 | journal=J. Psychopharmacol. (Oxford) | pages=621–32 | last1 = Griffiths | first1 = R | last2 = Richards | first2 = W | last3 = Johnson | first3 = M | last4 = McCann | first4 = U | last5 = Jesse | first5 = R| pmc=3050654 }}
51. ^{{cite journal | pmid= 21674151 | doi=10.1007/s00213-011-2358-5 | volume=218 | issue=4 | title=Psilocybin occasioned mystical-type experiences: immediate and persisting dose-related effects | pmc=3308357 | date=December 2011 | journal=Psychopharmacology | pages=649–65 | last1 = Griffiths | first1 = RR | last2 = Johnson | first2 = MW | last3 = Richards | first3 = WA | last4 = Richards | first4 = BD | last5 = McCann | first5 = U | last6 = Jesse | first6 = R}}
52. ^{{cite journal | pmid=21956378 | doi=10.1177/0269881111420188 | volume=25 |issue = 11| title=Mystical experiences occasioned by the hallucinogen psilocybin lead to increases in the personality domain of openness | date=November 2011 | journal=J. Psychopharmacol. (Oxford) | pages=1453–61 | last1 = MacLean | first1 = KA | last2 = Johnson | first2 = MW | last3 = Griffiths | first3 = RR| pmc=3537171 }}
53. ^Murray, ED.; Cunningham MG, Price BH. (1). "The role of psychotic disorders in religious history considered". J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neuroscience 24 (4): 410–26. doi:10.1176/appi.neuropsych.11090214. {{PMID|23224447}}
54. ^{{cite web|url=http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleID=434D7C62-E7F2-99DF-37CC9814533B90D7 |title=Searching for God in the Brain|accessdate=2007-10-07 |last=Biello |first=David |date=2007-10-03 |publisher=Scientific American |archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20071011195305/http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleID=434D7C62-E7F2-99DF-37CC9814533B90D7 |archivedate = 2007-10-11}}
55. ^{{cite web|url=http://cnn.health.printthis.clickability.com/pt/cpt?action=cpt&title=Are+humans+hard-wired+for+faith%3F+-+CNN.com&expire=&urlID=21822630&fb=Y&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnn.com%2F2007%2FHEALTH%2F04%2F04%2Fneurotheology%2Findex.html&partnerID=2012 |title=Are humans hard-wired for faith? |accessdate=2007-04-09 |last=Gajilan |first=A. Chris |date=2007-04-05 |publisher=Cable News Network}}
56. ^{{Cite journal|last=Azari|first=N. P. |last2=Nickel |first2=J. |last3=Wunderlich |first3=G. |last4=Niedeggen |first4=M. |last5=Hefter |first5=H. |last6=Tellmann |first6=L. |last7=Herzog |first7=H. |last8=Stoerig |first8=P. |last9=Birnbacher |first9=D. |date=April 2001 | title=Neural correlates of religious experience|journal=The European Journal of Neuroscience|volume=13|issue=8|pages=1649–1652|issn=0953-816X|pmid=11328359 |doi=10.1046/j.0953-816x.2001.01527.x}}
57. ^Schleiermacher, F.D.E. (1958). On Religion: Speeches to its Cultured Despisers. [translation Oman, J.]. Harper & Row, New York
58. ^James, W. (1902) Varieties of Religious Experience. Longs, Greens, New York
59. ^{{Cite book|url=https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2016/entries/personalism/|title=The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy|last=Williams|first=Thomas D.|last2=Bengtsson|first2=Jan Olof|date=2016|publisher=Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University|editor-last=Zalta|editor-first=Edward N.|edition=Summer 2016}}
60. ^{{Cite journal|last=Schjoedt|first=Uffe|title=The neural correlates of religious experience|journal=Religion|volume=41|issue=1|pages=91–95|doi=10.1080/0048721x.2011.553132|year=2011}}
61. ^¹{{Cite book|title=The Neuroscience of Religious Experience|last=McNamara|first=Patrick|publisher=Cambridge University Press|year=2009|isbn=978-0521889582|location=Cambridge|pages=2}}
62. ^{{cite journal | last1 = D'Onofrio | first1 = B.M. | last2 = Eaves | first2 = L.J. | last3 = Murrelle | first3 = L. | last4 = Maes | first4 = H.H. | last5 = Spilka | first5 = B. | year = 1999 | title = Understanding biological and social influences on religious affiliation, attitudes, and behaviors: A behavior genetic perspective | url = | journal = Journal of Personality | volume = 67 | issue = 6| pages = 953–984 | doi=10.1111/1467-6494.00079}}
63. ^S. Mithen. "The prehistory of the mind: The cognitive origins of art and science." Thames and Hudson, London (1996)
64. ^{{cite journal | last1 = Previc | first1 = F.H. | year = 1999 | title = Dopamine and the origins of human intelligence | url = | journal = Brain and Cognition | volume = 41 | issue = 3| pages = 299–350 | doi=10.1006/brcg.1999.1129| pmid = 10585240 }}
65. ^{{Cite journal|last=Previc|first=Fred H.|title=The role of the extrapersonal brain systems in religious activity|journal=Consciousness and Cognition|volume=15|issue=3|pages=500–539|doi=10.1016/j.concog.2005.09.009|pmid=16439158|year=2006}}
66. ^{{Cite journal|last=Hoyer|first=D.|last2=Clarke|first2=D. E.|last3=Fozard|first3=J. R.|last4=Hartig|first4=P. R.|last5=Martin|first5=G. R.|last6=Mylecharane|first6=E. J.|last7=Saxena|first7=P. R.|last8=Humphrey|first8=P. P.|date=June 1994|title=International Union of Pharmacology classification of receptors for 5-hydroxytryptamine (Serotonin)|journal=Pharmacological Reviews|volume=46|issue=2|pages=157–203|issn=0031-6997|pmid=7938165}}
67. ^{{Cite journal|last=Bentall|first=R. P.|date=January 1990|title=The illusion of reality: a review and integration of psychological research on hallucinations|journal=Psychological Bulletin|volume=107|issue=1|pages=82–95|issn=0033-2909|pmid=2404293|doi=10.1037/0033-2909.107.1.82}}
68. ^{{cite web |title=God on the Brain? |url=http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2003/godonbrain.shtml |website=BBC}}
69. ^{{Cite journal |title=This Is Your Brain on God |url=https://www.wired.com/wired/archive/7.11/persinger.html |journal=Wired|date=November 1999 }}
70. ^{{Cite journal| doi = 10.1046/j.0953-816x.2001.01527.x| last1 = Azari | first1 = N. P.| last2 = Nickel | first2 = J.| last3 = Wunderlich | first3 = G.| last4 = Niedeggen | first4 = M.| last5 = Hefter | first5 = H.| last6 = Tellmann | first6 = L.| last7 = Herzog | first7 = H.| last8 = Stoerig | first8 = P.| last9 = Birnbacher | first9 = D.| last10 = Seitz | first10 = R. J.| title = Neural correlates of religious experience| journal = The European Journal of Neuroscience| volume = 13| issue = 8| pages = 1649–1652| year = 2001| pmid = 11328359}}
71. ^{{cite web |title=From Brain Imaging Religious Experience to Explaining Religion: A Critique. |url=http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/brill/arp/2007/00000029/00000001/art00005 |website=Ingenta Connect}}
72. ^{{cite web |title=The new science of neurotheology. |url=http://neurophilosophy.wordpress.com/2006/03/16/the-new-science-of-neurotheology/ |website=Neurophilosophy}}
73. ^{{cite journal | last1 = Newberg | first1 = A. | last2 = Alavi | first2 = A. | last3 = Baime | first3 = M. | last4 = Pourdehnad | first4 = M. | last5 = Santanna | first5 = J. | last6 = Aquili | first6 = E. | year = 2001 | title = The measurement of regional cerebral blood flow during the complex cognitive task of meditation: A preliminary SPECT study | url = | journal = Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging | volume = 106 | issue = 2| pages = 113–122 | doi=10.1016/s0925-4927(01)00074-9}}
74. ^¹{{cite journal | last1 = Azari | first1 = N.P. | last2 = Missimer | first2 = J. | last3 = Seitz | first3 = R.J. | year = 2005 | title = Religious experience and emotion: Evidence for distinctive cognitive neural patterns | url = | journal = International Journal for the Psychology of Religion | volume = 15 | issue = 4| pages = 263–281 | doi=10.1207/s15327582ijpr1504_1}}
75. ^{{cite journal | last1 = Beauregard | first1 = M. | last2 = Paquette | first2 = V. | year = 2006 | title = Neural correlates of a mystical experience in Carmelite nuns | url = | journal = Neuroscience Letters | volume = 405 | issue = 3| pages = 186–190 | doi=10.1016/j.neulet.2006.06.060 | pmid=16872743}}
76. ^{{cite book |author=Newberg, Andrew B.; D'Aquili, Eugene G.; Rause, Vince |title=Why God Won't Go Away: Brain Science and the Biology of Belief |url=http://www.andrewnewberg.com/why.asp |publisher=Ballantine Books |location=New York |year=2002 |isbn=978-0-345-44034-1 |page=90}}
77. ^Ellison CG, Levin JS. The religion-health connection: evidence, theory, and future directions. Health Educ Behav 1998;25:700–20.
78. ^Koening HG. Research on religion, spirituality, and mental health: a review. Can J Psychiatry 2009;54:283–91.
79. ^{{Cite journal|last=Tedrus|first=Glória Maria Almeida Souza|last2=Fonseca|first2=Lineu Corrêa|last3=Höehr|first3=Gabriela Chaves|title=Spirituality aspects in patients with epilepsy|journal=Seizure|volume=23|issue=1|pages=25–28|doi=10.1016/j.seizure.2013.09.005|pmid=24094727|year=2014}}
80. ^Geschwind Ν (1983) Interictal behavioral changes in epilepsy. Epilepsia 24 Supplement 1:523-530
81. ^Landtblom AM. The sensed presence: an epileptic aura with religious overtones. Epilepsy Behav 2006;9:186–8.
82. ^Devinsky O. Religious experiences and epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav 2003;4:76–7
83. ^{{Cite journal | doi = 10.1016/j.yebeh.2009.06.006| title = Norman Geschwind's contribution to the understanding of behavioral changes in temporal lobe epilepsy: The February 1974 lecture| journal = Epilepsy & Behavior| volume = 15| issue = 4| pages = 417–24| year = 2009| last1 = Devinsky | first1 = J. | last2 = Schachter | first2 = S. | pmid = 19640791}}
84. ^Trimble M, Freeman A. An investigation of religiosity and the Gastaut-Geschwind syndrome in patient with temporal lobe epilepsy. Epilepsy Behav 2006;9:407–14.
85. ^Sloan RP, Bagliella E, Powell T. Religion, spirituality, and medicine. Lancet 1999;353: 664–7.
86. ^¹²³⁴⁵⁶⁷Previc FH. The role of the extrapersonal brain systems in religious activity. Conscious Cogn. 2006;15:500–539.
87. ^{{cite book |last=Crowley |first=Vivianne |title=Jung: A Journey of Transformation:Exploring His Life and Experiencing His Ideas|year=2000 |publisher=Quest Books |location=Wheaton Illinois |isbn=978-0-8356-0782-7 }}
88. ^{{cite book |last=Jung, C. G.|title=C. G. Jung speaking: Interviews and encounters(W. McGuire & R. F. C. Hull Eds.)|year=1980 |publisher=London: Pan Books}}
89. ^{{cite book |last=Main, R. |title=The rupture of time: Synchronicity and Jung's critique of modern western culture|year=2004|publisher=Hove and New York: Brunner-Routledge}}