Plumley enlisted in the United States Army as a private on March 31, 1942. He was a gliderman of the 320th Glider Field Artillery Battalion, 82nd Airborne Division. He saw action during the Invasion of Normandy, and Operation Market Garden.
Plumley participated in two glider assaults in the European Theater. His first was on June 6, 1944, during the Invasion of Normandy, and his second was for Operation Market Garden on Sept. 18, 1944. Plumley was shot in the hand the same day for which he received the Purple Heart and was awarded multiple decorations for his service in World War II.
Basil Plumley was stationed between 1951 through February 26, 1953 at Fort Campbell, Kentucky then he went to serve in Germany. He then fought in Korea during the final months of the Korean War, where he served at The Battle of Old Baldy, as well as the Battle of Pork Chop Hill. For serving in Korea, Plumley received his 2nd Combat Infantryman Badge in 1953.{{citation needed|date=January 2019}}
He fought in Vietnam with the 1st Battalion, 7th Cavalry Regiment. He participated in the Battle of Ia Drang in Vietnam in 1965, under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore, who praised Plumley as an outstanding NCO and leader in the 1992 book about this battle, We Were Soldiers Once… and Young. The book was the basis for the 2002 film We Were Soldiers, in which Plumley was played by actor Sam Elliott. Plumley was known affectionately by his soldiers as "Old Iron Jaw".
Command Sergeant Major Basil Plumley served in the Republic of Korea between 1972 and 1973.
He retired as a command sergeant major on December 31, 1974, having been awarded 28 different personal, unit, campaign and service awards and decorations in almost 33 years of military service, spanning World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War. After his retirement, he worked 15 more years for the army as a civilian in administration at Martin Army Community Hospital and at various medical clinics around Fort Benning, Georgia, retiring again in 1990.[1]
Plumley was born on January 1, 1920, in Shady Spring, West Virginia, the second son and fifth child of coal miner Clay H. Plumley (September 19, 1879[2] – 26 February 1952[3]) and his wife Georgia B. Morton (January 19, 1895[4] – February 16, 1962[3]), both of whom were natives of West Virginia. After two years of high-school, he worked as a chauffeur/driver before enlisting in the US Army on March 31, 1942. In 1948/49, Plumley married Deurice Dillon, who died on May 28, 2012, after 63 years of marriage. Plumley died of cancer after nine days in Columbus Hospice (Columbus, Georgia), on October 10, 2012. He is survived by his daughter, Debbie Kimble, a granddaughter, and two great-grandchildren.[3]
There have been disputes about the medals and decorations Plumley was entitled to wear and allegations by Brian Siddall in 2015 that Plumley wore unauthorized combat and valor awards that exaggerated his wartime achievements.[5][6][7] The resolving of the dispute is hampered by the death of Plumley three years prior to the allegations and the personnel records of the army, that are not uncommon to be in error, especially during war times and prior to electronic files.
Comparison of Awards and Decorations of CSM Plumley |
---|
name of award | listed on his DD 214 in 1974 [7] | worn in 2010 at West Point [8]{{Better source|reason=per WP:CIRCULAR|date=March 2019}} | verifiable by memo of the Army 2015 [7] | notes |
Combat Infantryman Badge | (2nd award, one star on top) | (3rd award, two stars on top) | (1st award, no star on top) | |
Legion of Merit | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Legion of Merit ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Legion of Merit ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Legion of Merit ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
Silver Star Medal with bronze Oak Leaf Cluster | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=Silver Star ribbon.svg|width=60}} (one oak leaf) | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=Silver Star ribbon.svg|width=60}} (one oak leaf) | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Silver Star ribbon.svg|width=60}} (no oak leaf) | |
Bronze Star Medal with "V" Device and bronze Oak Leaf Cluster | {{ribbon devices|number=2|type=oak|other_device=v|ribbon=Bronze Star ribbon.svg|width=60}} ("V" Device, two oak leaf) | {{ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|other_device=v|ribbon=Bronze Star ribbon.svg|width=60}} ("V" Device, one oak leaf) | {{ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=Bronze Star ribbon.svg|width=60}} (no "V" Device, one oak leaf) | |
Air Medal with numeral device or Oak Leaf Cluster | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Air Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (with numeral "7") | {{Ribbon devices|number=8|type=oak|ribbon=Air Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (eight oak leaf) | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Air Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (with numeral "7") | |
Army Commendation Medal | {{ribbon devices|number=3|type=oak|ribbon=Army Commendation Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (three oak leaf) | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Army Commendation Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (no oak leaf) | {{ribbon devices|number=3|type=oak|ribbon=Army Commendation Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (three oak leaf) | |
Purple Heart with one Oak Leaf Cluster | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=Purple Heart ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=Purple Heart ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=Purple Heart ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
Army Good Conduct Medal with good conduct loops | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Army_Good_Conduct_Ribbon.jpg|width=60}} (silver clasp and three loops = 8 awards) | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Army_Good_Conduct_Ribbon.jpg|width=60}} (silver clasp and one loop = 6 awards) | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Army_Good_Conduct_Ribbon.jpg|width=60}} (silver clasp and three loops = 8 awards) | |
American Defense Service Medal | n/a | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=American Defense Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | n/a | only available for service between September 8, 1939 and December 7, 1941 |
American Campaign Medal | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=American Campaign Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=American Campaign Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=American Campaign Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign Medal with Arrowhead device, silver and bronze campaign stars | {{Ribbon devices|number=6|type=service-star|other_device=arrowhead|ribbon=European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign ribbon.svg|width=60}} (arrowhead, 1 silver star, 1 bronze star) | {{Ribbon devices|number=7|type=service-star|other_device=arrowhead|ribbon=European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign ribbon.svg|width=60}} (arrowhead, 1 silver star, 2 bronze stars) | {{Ribbon devices|number=6|type=service-star|other_device=arrowhead|ribbon=European-African-Middle Eastern Campaign ribbon.svg|width=60}} (arrowhead, 1 silver star, 1 bronze star) | |
World War II Victory Medal | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=World War II Victory Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=World War II Victory Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=World War II Victory Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
Army of Occupation Medal with "Germany" clasp | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Army of Occupation ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Army of Occupation ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Army of Occupation ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
National Defense Service Medal with bronze service star or bronze Oak Leave Cluster | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=service-star|ribbon=National Defense Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (bronze star) | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=National Defense Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (bronze oak leaf) | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=service-star|ribbon=National Defense Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (bronze star) | |
Vietnam Service Medal with one silver and three bronze campaign stars | {{Ribbon devices|number=8|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (1 silver star, 3 bronze stars) | {{Ribbon devices|number=3|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (3 bronze stars) | {{Ribbon devices|number=8|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} (1 silver star, 3 bronze stars) | |
Korea Defense Service Medal | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Korea Defense Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | not worn | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Korea Defense Service Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | awarded since February 2004 (retroactive to July 28, 1954) |
Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
French Croix de Guerre (for World War II service) | unclear | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Ruban de la croix de guerre 1939-1945.PNG|width=60}} | unclear | noted in the memo is "French Fourragère" |
Belgian Croix de Guerre (for World War II service) | unclear | | unclear | noted in the memo is "Belgian Fourragère" |
Vietnam Cross of Gallantry with Gold Star | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Vietnamese Gallantry Cross ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Vietnamese Gallantry Cross ribbon.svg|width=60}} | {{ribbon devices|number=0|type=oak|ribbon=Vietnamese Gallantry Cross ribbon.svg|width=60}} | matching |
Republic of Vietnam Armed Forces Honor Medal, second class | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Armed Forces Honor Medal ribbon-Second Class.svg|width=60}} | not worn | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Armed Forces Honor Medal ribbon-Second Class.svg|width=60}} | |
Vietnam Campaign Medal with "1960–" device | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Campaign Medal ribbon with 60- clasp.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Campaign Medal ribbon with 60- clasp.svg|width=60}} | {{Ribbon devices|number=0|type=service-star|ribbon=Vietnam Campaign Medal ribbon with 60- clasp.svg|width=60}} | matching |
Master Parachutist Badge | | | | matching |
Glider Badge | | not worn | | |
Netherlands Orange Lanyard | no picture | not worn | no picture | |
| | | | |
Republic of Vietnam Parachutist Badge with palm device (= Republic of Vietnam Master Parachutist Badge) | | | | matching |
Vietnam Gallantry Cross Unit Citation with Palm | | | | matching |
Army Presidential Unit Citation with bronze Oak Leaf Clusters | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=United States Army and U.S. Air Force Presidential Unit Citation ribbon.svg|width=60}} (1 oak leaf) | {{Ribbon devices|number=2|type=oak|ribbon=United States Army and U.S. Air Force Presidential Unit Citation ribbon.svg|width=60}} (2 oak leaf) | {{Ribbon devices|number=1|type=oak|ribbon=United States Army and U.S. Air Force Presidential Unit Citation ribbon.svg|width=60}} (1 oak leaf) | |
Republic of Vietnam Civil Actions Honor Medal unit citation first class | | not worn | | |
1. ^Associated Press, "Plumley, veteran of 3 wars, dies at age 92", Military Times, 10 October 2012
2. ^United States, Selective Service System. World War I Selective Service System Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918. Washington, D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration. M1509, 4,582 rolls. Imaged from Family History Library microfilm.
3. ^1 "West Virginia Deaths, 1853–1970." Index. FamilySearch, Salt Lake City, Utah. From originals housed in county courthouses throughout West Virginia. "Death Records."
4. ^"West Virginia Births, 1853–1930." Index. FamilySearch, Salt Lake City, Utah, 2008, 2009. From digital images of copies of originals housed in County Courthouses throughout West Virginia. Birth records.
5. ^Matthew Cox: [https://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/05/17/army-investigating-we-were-soldiers-legend-for-inflating-award.html Army Investigating 'We Were Soldiers' Legend for Inflating Awards], Military.com, 2018
6. ^Brian Siddall: The Original Plumley Article, Airborne In Normandy, 2015
7. ^1 2 Army HR Memo about Awards and Decorations for CSM Plumley, Department of the Army, U.S. Army Human Resources Command, Awards and Decorations Branch, 2015
8. ^File:CSM(R) Basil L. Plumley at West Point 10 May 2010.JPG
9. ^1 {{cite web|last=Associated Press|title=Basil Plumley, veteran of 3 wars, featured in 'We Were Soldiers' movie, dies in Georgia|url=http://www.foxnews.com/entertainment/2012/10/10/basil-plumley-retired-veteran-whose-book-became-were-soldiers-movie-dies-in/|publisher=FoxNews.com|accessdate=2012-10-11|date=October 10, 2012}}
10. ^1 2 {{cite web|title=Deurice Plumley Obituary|url=http://www.legacy.com/obituaries/ledger-enquirer/obituary.aspx?n=Deurice-Plumley&pid=157839404|publisher=Columbus Ledger-Enquirer (by Legacy.com)|date=May 29, 2012}}